4 ms·
So, is there such a site for the transcripts for those videos? I'm old fashioned and read much faster than a human can talk, so I don't see the reason to spend
by nottorp 8y ago
So, is there such a site for the transcripts for those videos? I'm old fashioned and read much faster than a human can talk, so I don't see the reason to spend 45 min watching a talking head.
- zelos 8y agoOr an edited transcript, with the source code samples copied inline and perhaps a bit more detail than someone would say out loud? Hang on, maybe we could put multiple talks about closely related subjects together with headings to separate them! Then have some sort of table of the subjects at the beginning to make them easy to find - a table of the 'contents' so to speak. This is a brilliant idea, I'm going to file my patent application now.
- nottorp 8y agoNot just yet, but wait another 30 years and it will look like a novel idea to everyone ;)
- gregjwild 8y agoWe do some of this - inline code samples, some of which can be executed, embedded headings, additional reference material, etc. https://livevideo.manning.com/module/3_2_2/es6-in-motion/arrow-functions/what-do-these-arrow-functions-do https://livevideo.manning.com/module/3_2_2/es6-in-motion/arr...
- ilovetux 8y agoI have experience with and equipment for transcription. If this site had the feature to add transcriptions, I would like to transcribe maybe one or two videos per week and I don't think I'm the only one who would. It would be a nice easy way to give back and possibly even garner some reputation/goodwill.
- Bromskloss 8y agoWhat is such equipment like?
- ilovetux 8y agoThe two most important pieces are a high-quality head-set and a foot-pedal to rewind/fast-forward. After that, a good ergonomic keyboard is very helpful. That's the bulk of it, but you can find other ways to spend money such as specialized software and hardware.
- gregjwild 8y agoWe (Manning Publications) added transcripts as a pretty central feature of our video platform. I'd be pretty interested to hear what you thought. A lot of our customers asked for this when we were researching what they wanted, so I'm always interested to see if people outside our usual user base like what we've done: https://livevideo.manning.com/module/31_1_2/algorithms-in-motion/introduction-to-algorithms/binary-search https://livevideo.manning.com/module/31_1_2/algorithms-in-mo...?
- modernerd 8y agoThis is excellent — I love the link between the transcript and the video. Being able to click the text and jump to that point in the video works fluidly; I can read ahead and jump to things I want to see explained visually. The presentation of the transcript is also much better than the broken-line-by-line approach that others such as YouTube take: https://d.pr/i/WvrOX5 https://d.pr/i/WvrOX5. This is the perfect combination of ebook and video for me, and I didn't know Manning was doing this. Some minor feedback: - I wish the transcript text size could be increased without affecting the rest of the UI (which seems fine). Maybe it can and I missed it, or I need to be logged in? - I see “pause on try its” in the page options (it's checked and disabled) but couldn't find any videos that use this. This feature sounds like it would greatly enhance the learning experience and it should be part of all videos. I learn a lot more when actively trying things than when passively watching and reading, and few online courses combine video and text transcripts with hands-on opportunities well. I just bought Algorithms in Motion on the back of this experience, though, (plus a couple of books I'd been considering) and am looking forward to going through the whole course.
- gregjwild 8y agoGlad to hear it! > - I wish the transcript text size could be increased without affecting the rest of the UI (which seems fine). Maybe it can and I missed it, or I need to be logged in? Totally agreed we need this. I've passed this feedback onto the developers (I'm in editorial here). > - I see “pause on try its” in the page options (it's checked and disabled) but couldn't find any videos that use this. This feature sounds like it would greatly enhance the learning experience and it should be part of all videos. I learn a lot more when actively trying things than when passively watching and reading, and few online courses combine video and text transcripts with hands-on opportunities well. Yep, we're still experimenting with this feature. I think you'll see us using it much, much more in future content.
- jasode 8y ago>I'm old fashioned and read much faster than a human can talk, so I don't see the reason to spend 45 min watching a talking head. I agree that people can read at 200+ wpm while most people only talk at ~100 wpm. However, some programming presentations are visually intensive with demonstrations of interactive features. That would be videos such as showing how an IDE works (debugging tips and tricks), CSS transforms, GUI workflow (e.g. navigate AWS admin screens to set up security, auto-scaling, etc). For example, I see that the landing page has severgal Google I/O keynotes and those are always heavy with demos. But yes, for presentations of static text such as explaining the new syntax for C++11, a "talking head" reading the slides may not add much value and just slow you down. As for transcripts... Since many videos seem to come from YouTube, it may be possible to download the auto-generated captions.[1] (I don't have a YouTube account so I have no idea how well this works.) I noticed one presentation where a speaker was talking about "Qt" framework but the Youtube's speech recognition auto-captioned it as "cute". I don't know if mistranslation is a rare and minor annoyance or if it makes the transcripts unusable. To downvoters: please let me know what I wrote that didn't add positive contribution to this discussion. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=download+youtube+captions&oq=download+youtube+captions https://www.google.com/search?q=download+youtube+captions&oq...
- Bromskloss 8y agoYou don't need a YouTube account to download things. Here's how to download captions using youtube-dl: https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl/#subtitle-options https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl/#subtitle-options I wouldn't bother with the automatically generated ones, though. They are not good enough. (Whenever there are real captions, I turn them on to be able to speed up the video beyond the point where I can no longer hear what people say. That's great!)
- jasode 8y ago>Whenever there are real captions, How can you tell if the captions are real vs auto-generated? Do you mean "real" as in subtitles that are burned into the video source instead of being dynamically overlaid?
- stojano 8y agoYoutube Playback Speed Control Extension works well here... and I can watch it im my comfort zone of 3.5x - 4.5x. So at least 45min get cut to 10-15min.. but tested only on one so far.
- eduardsi 8y agoThanks for testing this. – Eduards
- RickJWagner 8y agoWow. I have trouble at 2x. You've got a gift, I think.
- skinnyarms 8y agoNicely done, I've always heard that we can listen about 4x faster than we can speak. Most podcast listeners I know do 1.5x - 2x speed, myself included.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lozf 8y agoFor Youtube (and most others) I usually just paste the URL to `mpv` (using youtube-dl under the hood) to take advantage of it's keyboard shortcuts for easy control over speed and position etc. I might be playing through a video really fast, but suddenly need to repeat something so hit backspace to drop to normal speed, a press or two of left arrow to jump back (~5 secs each), then tap ] a few times to speed up again. Then if there's an interesting chart or graph shown, just f to toggle full screen, s for screenshot if you like. Being able to navigate and control linear media with simple keyboard shortcuts feels liberating in a similar way to the first time you grok a powerful edit with just a few keystrokes in Vim or Emacs (except you're just consuming media of course).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]