3 ms·
Shouldn't the title be '..humanity may be the only detectable advanced civilization..'? After all, the last two terms of the Drake Equation are all about detec
by jcims 8y ago
Shouldn't the title be '..humanity may be the only detectable advanced civilization..'?
After all, the last two terms of the Drake Equation are all about detectability, and what are the chances that a civilization outside the Milky Way would emit a signal that we could possibly detect? Just slapping a couple of internet calculators together, you'd get about 500dB of loss from Andromeda (our closest galactic neighbor) to us, requiring a 1x10^41 watt omnidirectional emission for us to receive a nanowatt signal. This is within a few orders of magnitude of a supernova. Even if you were to focus the beam, the transmitting civilization would likely scorch planets within a couple hundred light years just to say hi.
The paper seemed to inconsistently pepper 'detectable' into the language and I lost interest before trying to figure out whether or not it included those terms (fc and L) in the final conclusion.
- em3rgent0rdr 8y agoYeah. Also the successful advanced civilizations might not even be emitting any signals at all.
- jcims 8y agoExactly. The 'L' term at the end (length of time advanced civilization is transmitting detectable signals) may be a very small window for most civilizations. Energy is precious. If you have the technology to put the signal where you want it to be, why would you spew it all over the universe?
- pattisapu 8y agoGood points--but you might still spew out your signal out all over the universe if you were still searching for advanced life.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]