2 ms·
I don't understand how papers like this end up on the homepage of HN. I don't understand what it is you don't understand. Clearly HN is not a site dedicated s
by mindcrime 8y ago
I don't understand how papers like this end up on the homepage of HN.
I don't understand what it is you don't understand. Clearly HN is not a site dedicated strictly to academics and people focused on the ceremony of academia. So if a paper contains even an idea that might be interesting, and seems likely to foster some interesting discussion, it's probably going to get upvotes. It making the front page or not presumably depends on which other stories are also contending for a front-page spot at the same time. In any case, getting a lot of upvotes doesn't mean that the paper was "good", that its conclusions were justified, or anything else. It just means it was something that people thought was worth talking about.
Missing citations (e.g. "It is well-known that NNs are prone to overfitting [Chollet and Allaire(2018)], which has been the subject of much study, e.g. [?].").
- Inconsistent formatting (e.g. the tables on page 7)
It's a pre-print, and not a published paper, no? My assumption was that the authors intended to fix those in a subsequent revision.
- sdenton4 8y agoAt least in my end of the world (math), typically the paper is sent for review and posted to arxiv at the same time; the paper should already pretty much meet the quality bar for publication. The ML community I think suffers from some (shall we say) poor sportsmanship, with people occasionally posting rather half-baked papers to establish priority on an idea, before it's even been fully fleshed out or explored. This paper feels like that, on both the 'science' and 'bothering to use reasonable LaTeX' fronts.
- mindcrime 8y agoAt least in my end of the world (math), typically the paper is sent for review and posted to arxiv at the same time; the paper should already pretty much meet the quality bar for publication. Ah, interesting. At first blush that seems like that kinda defeats the purpose of releasing a pre-print, but I can kinda see why someone might do it that way.