3 ms·
I've long thought that the vesting-equity model is wrong, and if I were free to design a compensation system I would set it up more or less as you describe: No
by cperciva 16y ago
I've long thought that the vesting-equity model is wrong, and if I were free to design a compensation system I would set it up more or less as you describe: No equity grants, but wages would be paid as a combination of cash and convertible debt. If someone leaves the company, they keep whatever they've been paid so far; they would be treated just the same as any other convertible debt holder. The debt would have a significant rate attached (say, 1% per month) due to its high risk.
Unfortunately, I don't think this would ever work, due to income tax issues. As I understand it, the convoluted games startups play with equity grants are to avoid having the equity taxed at its real value; but I imagine that the IRS would demand that income taxes be paid immediately on the total wages, including the value of the debt -- which would very quickly create a cash flow crunch for all but the wealthiest employees.
If this were possible, though, it would make things much simpler -- just imagine, having founders, employees, and angel investors all hold the same form of equity!
EDIT: Just to be clear, I would say that the cash+debt model should continue indefinitely, rather than being limited to 4 years. The idea that someone's effective salary should drop dramatically 4 years after they were hired (i.e., when they are no longer vesting stock each month) seems absolutely loony to me.
- yrashk 16y agoThe tax issue is very important, indeed. I would try to get some consultations about that. I wonder want might be the difference between CRA and IRS in this respect (I'm from Canada) P.S. You're giving a talk at Vancouver's hackathon this October, right?
- cperciva 16y agoI wonder want might be the difference between CRA and IRS in this respect I vaguely remember seeing something in the T1 guide about handling wages owed but not received... it's just possible that this would cover things, but I don't remember looking into the details. P.S. You're giving a talk at Vancouver's hackathon this October, right? Yep. Evening of October 9th.