5 ms·
Depends on what you are trying to prove. If that "ordinary men following orders and under expectation can be total bastards" then it's just Milgram's experimen
by scotty79 8y ago
Depends on what you are trying to prove.
If that "ordinary men following orders and under expectation can be total bastards" then it's just Milgram's experiment all over again which result is itself obvious for any historian.
And if you are trying to prove that "ordinary men in position of power in jail setting spontaneously become total bastards" then the experiment is crap for that purpose if guards were encouraged to behave that way.
I don't think anybody doubts human capacity for cruelty.
The thing that Zimbardo built celebrity status on crap experiment and he still is a scientist and people give weight to his opinions on other psychology related subjects rubs some people the wrong way, I guess.
- CamperBob2 8y agoIf that "ordinary men following orders and under expectation can be total bastards" then it's just Milgram's experiment all over again which result is itself obvious for any historian. But as I pointed out in the other thread ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17289154 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17289154 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17289386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17289386 ), Milgram has his own detractors. His conclusions were far from obvious to many, and are still controversial today. And it's true that his work was not above criticism. It seems you can't touch this subject on HN without getting personal, though. Unjustifiably-flagged comments and scores clamped to the -4 minimum are the order of the day. I'm not a psychologist and have only a casual interest in the subject, so my experience in the last thread was like stumbling into a bar fight that I didn't know was going on. I suspect this thread will evolve along similar lines, but it's hard to be sure without conducting a formal study that will probably come under heavy dispute. /s And if you are trying to prove that "ordinary men in position of power in jail setting spontaneously become total bastards" then the experiment is crap for that purpose if guards were encouraged to behave that way. As everdev points out, that's the whole idea behind prison guard training! If you insist on studying these scenarios in a sterile, painstakingly-ethical academic environment, you will always be left scratching your head when an Abu Ghraib or a My Lai or a Guantanamo happens, wondering why reality stubbornly refuses to conform to your approved methodology.
- AstralStorm 8y agoIf you want to run experiments on soldiers, then run them on soldiers. If you're trying to prove a more general point, you do have to be much more careful. After all, if you do train your subjects to be soldiers or to blindly follow orders this does not prove the general point anymore. If you additionally filter your experimental group (as typicalsoldier training does) then the point is even less general. So you're missing the point. Now, a study on how effective military training is at instilling blind obedience is still very useful and important.
- rusk 8y ago> I'm not a psychologist ... > that's the whole idea behind prison guard training! If you insist on studying these scenarios in a sterile, painstakingly-ethical Thing is though, when the behaviour emerges you can't see if it's to do with the training, or the mere adoption of the prison guard role. When you "condition" your participants to behave in a particular way then that can become a confounding factor and then when it comes time to appraise the results you can be left scratching your head. Precisely what you want to understand when an Abu Ghraib scenario occurs is whether it could be the training or innate characteristic emerging from the role. Of course you could do a between-groups study where some were conditioned and some weren't but what would that prove? That the conditioning had the expected effect?
- everdev 8y ago> And if you are trying to prove that "ordinary men in position of power in jail setting spontaneously become total bastards" then the experiment is crap for that purpose if guards were encouraged to behave that way. I think they were told to act in a dominant manner because actual prison guards are trained on how to be dominant.
- wslack 8y agoBeing encouraged to be "tough" and creating rituals of humiliation are different IMO.
- JdeBP 8y agoActually, "React as you imagine pigs reacting." according to this self-published source. According to another source from a decade ago by the very same author and published by Random House, a somewhat longer instruction: > The guards have to know that every guard has to be what we call a "tough guard" [...] we need you to act a certain way. For the time being, we need you to play the role of "tough guard". We need you to react as you imagine the pigs would. We're trying to set up the stereotype guard – your individual style has been a little too soft. Not "real prison guards", but "pigs", which latter carried in the 1970s a whole bunch of connotations that the former does not. As does "stereotype guard".