5 ms·
Can we kill the IE-should-be-built-on-webkit meme? One of the web's strengths is the wide range of independent and compatible implementations. Yes, the differe
by nl 16y ago
Can we kill the IE-should-be-built-on-webkit meme? One of the web's strengths is the wide range of independent and compatible implementations.
Yes, the differences suck when you are dealing with CSS incompatibility problems, but when you look at the big picture it remains vitally important.
- pornel 16y agoWhile we're at this, please kill IE9-on-non-Windows too. End users who chose not to use Microsoft OS are unlikely to choose Microsoft browser, especially when they have better, native browsers available out of the box. Porting IE9 to other platforms is a lot of work for a "nice to have" feature for web developers. Such effort is better spent on making IE suck less on its only platform.
- swombat 16y agoOne meme I don't want to kill is, God damn it, Microsoft... release an app that allows web developers to test in IE6-9 on the same machine, without needing lots of VMs. Spoon.net goes some of the way, but IE9 won't work on my XP box. So I'll need to reinstall Windows 7. Which means Synergy will stop working again. Blah.
- ghurlman 16y agoExpression Web. Superpreview. Works as advertised through IE8 anyway, including testing via Safari on OSX remotely (in beta).
- jan_g 16y agoWhile I agree with grandparent's take on webkit meme, I don't agree with your take on multi-platform meme. IE-on-other-platforms meme will never die, because this is an important issue for many people. For major releases, like IE9, they could have taken another approach. Like, for example, abstracted many components (css/html engine, js engine, plugins framework, etc.) from the underlying OS and then port just the bridge between those components and underlying OS. It's not easy and there're always many quirks, but we're talking about Microsoft, after all.
- confuzatron 16y agoMS making their browser work on other OS's makes about as much sense as MS making their file system explorer app work on other OS's.
- jan_g 16y agoHm, no. Internet explorer is used to view content of the publicly available documents. File explorer is nothing of the sort. I would rather parallel IE to various document viewers (.doc viewer, for example) which Microsoft provides free of charge. And which, sadly, also aren't available for other platforms.
- confuzatron 16y agoOK: There is no earthly reason why MS would want to add massively to the development effort of IE (test matrices, abstraction layers, etc etc), in ways that would in no way benefit their customers. Their goal is to provide the best browser tailored to the OS that they sell. And the idea (by extension) that any app that works with standards-based content should be cross-platform is barmy.
- jan_g 16y agoI understand there's additional effort needed. What I don't understand is, why you and some others keep repeating that it's such big problem to solve. It really isn't, based on my experience. There's nothing massive about it. If nothing else, they could open-source it, since it's already free and someone else will write a port. Layout engine(css+html) and js engine would suffice for most use-cases.
- confuzatron 16y agoNo, I am arguing that it is a problem which they have absolutely no incentive to solve. They're trying to sell Windows licenses. They have no reason to sweat to make a hardware accelerated IE work on OSX, I'm baffled that people think it'd make sense for them.
- shadowsun7 16y agoOne of the web's strengths is the wide range of independent and compatible implementations. What do you mean by this? Am genuinely curious, because I've always raged at the lack of browser standardization.
- logophobia 16y agoBecause: * Mono-cultures are bad security-wise, it's harder to target multiple platforms with different vulnerabilities then one platform (which is one of the reasons IE had such a bad reputation for a long time) * It prevent people from coding to specific browser bugs/quirks. When there are a lot of platforms it is easier to code to standards (if they are consistently implemented across browsers) then specific platforms. Theoretically at least..
- jasonlotito 16y agoYou should also keep in mind that even WebKit isn't standardized. Webkit rendering is wide and varied.
- nl 16y agoMultiple implementations: a) Force specifications to written carefully, and exercise the edge cases. It's important the browser authors do this because otherwise web pages authors are forced to find these edge cases (as happened in the IE6 & early IE7 days, when MS had so little competition that they could afford to be careless) b) Slow down change the core technologies. This sounds like a stupid "advantage", but I'd argue that it has enabled the core HTML/CSS/Javascript trinity to become so well established that any new platform is forced to support it. Ironically, that also means new platforms become viable simply by supporting the web platform. c) Allow multiple paths for experimenting on new technologies.