4 ms·
> b.lock saves the encrypted passwords/secret notes on the Nebulas blockchain What possible benefit could there be to storing my secrets in a public blockchain
by GordonS 8y ago
> b.lock saves the encrypted passwords/secret notes on the Nebulas blockchain
What possible benefit could there be to storing my secrets in a public blockchain rather than private storage? I only see downsides.
The readme mention 2 'problems' with existing solutions:
"Single point of failure: if the server/database goes down, there goes your passwords"
This is not a reason to use a blockchain - it's a reason to use a highly available system.
"Trust issue: can you really trust that these closed-source softwares will not just read your passwords?"
This is not a reason to use a blockchain - it's a reason to use OSS.
- Tijdreiziger 8y agoThat's discussed on the linked page (under the 'Why blockchain?' heading).
- the_snooze 8y agoI'm not seeing the benefit either. If your credentials are stored under strong encryption, then it's the encryption that's providing a confidentiality and integrity assurance, wholly independent of blockchain or any other storage solution.
- brighton36 8y agoA blockchain is a database with virtue. This solution provides social acceptance.
- beaner 8y agoCentralized systems aren't vulnerable just because of uptime. They can also terminate your access at will, like if you forget to pay a bill, or if some government actor comes knocking on their door.
- KaiserPro 8y agoAnd spaffing your encrypted secrets to the wind allows anyone to have a go at cracking your keychain. YEah its "universally available" but so is having a few git repos, or god forbid one's own server or two. Blockchain has very limited use outside of a system that has lots of money and requires zero trust immutable log of things, which can tolerate very high latency and long period of inconsistency (ie a trading platform.)
- craigc 8y agoThe fact that the data is encrypted means that it can literally be stored anywhere. You can throw it in a local file or in Dropbox/Google Drive/iCloud. The trust issue also doesn’t matter cause if the encryption is right, then third parties wouldn’t be able to read your data even if they wanted to.
- agorabinary 8y ago> Private storage Easier to store a private key that gives access to a blockchain datastore than to store a decryption key + private storage file that would need to be replicated across all systems you want password access. > HA system That's a hosted solution, so it isn't completely trustless. > closed-source softwares will not just read your passwords I agree that this has nothing to do with a blockchain.
- GordonS 8y ago> That's a hosted solution, so it isn't completely trustless If the secrets are encrypted, I don't see how there is any more of a trust issue with a hosted storage system than with a public blockchain?
- 21 8y ago> What possible benefit could there be to storing my secrets in a public blockchain rather than private storage? I only see downsides. This is why you are poor. You wrap this in an ICO and easily make a million dollars.