19 ms·
"The Dogma of Otherness insists that all voices deserve a hearing, that all points of view have something of value to offer." This might have been a dogma amon
by pmoriarty 8y ago
"The Dogma of Otherness insists that all voices deserve a hearing, that all points of view have something of value to offer."
This might have been a dogma amongst most Americans in 1986 (though I seriously doubt it, considering the rampant anti-Communism, sexism, homophobia, and conservatism of the time), but these days, with anti-Muslim and anti-Mexican xenophobia being virtually the law of the land, with a neo-Nazi sympathizer in the White House, with all branches of government and a huge percentage of the electorate controlled by his racist, bigoted party, it's hard to read this sort of essay without laughing, crying, or raging.
- narag 8y agoI disagree with the author that zeitgeist and dogma are the same thing. Dogma is something imposed top-down from cultural elites. Current dogma is multiculturalism and relativism (or "otherness" following the article). Trumpism is against it.
- Avshalom 8y agoAt what point did the president of the united states and both branches of congress stop being the "top" and at what point did the majority of the population start being "elites"
- belorn 8y agoWhile the president is at the military top, a common view is that there exist an ruling class or political elite that holds power within political parties through generations. Politicians may come and go but the same families holds influence. Wikipedia has an article called Elite theory (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory) which describe this, and the key trait is that those people hold power that is independent of democratic elections. Is this theory true or false? I don't personally have a definitive opinion but I think it is important to understand the argument when people are talking about the cultural elites.
- narag 8y agoSo for you Trump represent the cultural elite? That explains a lot.
- Avshalom 8y agoNo I believe the entire framing is invalid because the majority cannot by definition be the elite and the federal government cannot not be the elite.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- andor 8y agoThe "Dogma of Otherness" might just be one of the reasons why those views are so popular, especially when paired with insufficient reasoning abilities: "Climate change? Sounds inconvenient, I'll just settle on a different opinion!" "Vaccinations? Don't trust doctors, I heard they cause autism!" "Science? I don't understand it, so it's probably not true!"