2 ms·
> I was a PulseAudio early adopter and like it better than raw ALSA since it covers more use cases like Bluetooth and provides some extra features. The last ti
by asveikau 8y ago
> I was a PulseAudio early adopter and like it better than raw ALSA since it covers more use cases like Bluetooth and provides some extra features.
The last time I had Bluetooth audio actually work, it was before it needed to be routed through pulse. Alsa applications played Bluetooth audio just fine. Then at some dist-upgrade it pulled in a new bluez and that no longer worked, and I literally could not get it working through pulse.
I actually have this experience 100% of the time with pulse: introduce pulse and everything breaks. When things talk to lower level pieces it works fine.
By the way, alsa itself is a little bit of a case study in confusion between api and implementation... My freebsd machines are using the oss audio API with none of the problems that plagued oss on Linux in the 90s.
- jchw 8y agoI am aware that there was a bluez-alsa adapter. I am sure it worked, but with pure ALSA there was a lot of issues that made hotpluggable audio devices tricky. I often had to mess with asound.conf and alsamixer to get things working correctly - and that sometimes also meant that I had to restart all my audio-using applications if I wanted to switch. And all of those problems occurred WITHOUT Bluetooth being thrown into the mix. I had multiple audio devices, including Intel HD Audio, an Audigy LS of some kind, and a USB microphone that presented it's own audio device to the system. (This was a while ago, I have no setups that look like this anymore.) I'd often have the devices come in a different order, and when this happened my mixer levels would be all messed up, and often times if I booted with the microphone plugged in... it'd be the default output device. With PulseAudio, I have less trouble - things do generally get setup how I expect it, and when they don't I can switch everything at runtime to be correct. It's worth noting that the trouble I have had with stability is heavily tied to hardware. Of course that doesn't mean it's not a PulseAudio issue, but I think a lot of people have trouble that they may not realize is not actually the normal PulseAudio experience. Even latency varies per hardware, in what I can only assume has something to do with how the audio hardware handles timings.