5 ms·
The Dogma of Otherness (1986)
- RichardCA 8y agoWhenever the subject of dolphin intelligence comes up, I go back to this video. It's from a PBS Frontline episode. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=511nWKjNFpw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=511nWKjNFpw
- pmoriarty 8y ago"The Dogma of Otherness insists that all voices deserve a hearing, that all points of view have something of value to offer." This might have been a dogma amongst most Americans in 1986 (though I seriously doubt it, considering the rampant anti-Communism, sexism, homophobia, and conservatism of the time), but these days, with anti-Muslim and anti-Mexican xenophobia being virtually the law of the land, with a neo-Nazi sympathizer in the White House, with all branches of government and a huge percentage of the electorate controlled by his racist, bigoted party, it's hard to read this sort of essay without laughing, crying, or raging.
- narag 8y agoI disagree with the author that zeitgeist and dogma are the same thing. Dogma is something imposed top-down from cultural elites. Current dogma is multiculturalism and relativism (or "otherness" following the article). Trumpism is against it.
- Avshalom 8y agoAt what point did the president of the united states and both branches of congress stop being the "top" and at what point did the majority of the population start being "elites"
- belorn 8y agoWhile the president is at the military top, a common view is that there exist an ruling class or political elite that holds power within political parties through generations. Politicians may come and go but the same families holds influence. Wikipedia has an article called Elite theory (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_theory) which describe this, and the key trait is that those people hold power that is independent of democratic elections. Is this theory true or false? I don't personally have a definitive opinion but I think it is important to understand the argument when people are talking about the cultural elites.
- narag 8y agoSo for you Trump represent the cultural elite? That explains a lot.
- Avshalom 8y agoNo I believe the entire framing is invalid because the majority cannot by definition be the elite and the federal government cannot not be the elite.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- andor 8y agoThe "Dogma of Otherness" might just be one of the reasons why those views are so popular, especially when paired with insufficient reasoning abilities: "Climate change? Sounds inconvenient, I'll just settle on a different opinion!" "Vaccinations? Don't trust doctors, I heard they cause autism!" "Science? I don't understand it, so it's probably not true!"
- Judgmentality 8y agoAt first I thought this was 'The Dogma of Otterness' and was curious what the hell that meant before realizing my mistake.
- mr_spothawk 8y ago> "And you'll agree that as a truly pervasive set of assumptions, it's pretty much a liberal Western, even American, tradition, won't you? Think how strange this Doctrine of Otherness would seem to an ancient Roman, or to the dynastic Chinese who thought the world revolved around Beijing, or to Tudor England, or to most of the peoples of the world today." it falls apart there, for me. I don't know what those other cultures appreciated. perhaps it was the case that every human in those societies were were entirely anti-other.. but I feel like it must have been the case that there were aspects of non-(ancient)-chinese culture that the Chinese appreciated, and adopted... else, we'd not have had any cultural exchange, ever
- jhbadger 8y agoIn most of history cultural exchange happened not by enlightened people seeking out other cultures, but through conquest. In the case of China, by the Mongols, for example. Or in the very language we are communicating in - which is a weird mixture of Germanic and French thanks to William the Conqueror.
- woodandsteel 8y agoVery interesting article. However, after he explained the dogma of otherness and got other people to agree that it is what they believe, it would have been a lot more direct to ask them if there is any way to determine if this belief is correct or not. He could also asked them why it is bad for people to believe in absolute truths. They likely would have answered that it leads to the West oppressing other nations, and then he could have pointed out that that the belief oppression is bad is a Western one, and not even all Westerners believe it, and many non-Western cultures believe quite differently. I have thought a lot about the D of O, and have come to the conclusion that the people who advocate it don't actually believe it. You can see this because they have absolute moral responses when another culture does something that clearly violates liberal norms, like female genital mutilation. And ditto when it comes to their evaluation of the views of other people in our own culture, like conservatives. The D of O advocates clearly believe that there are absolute factual and moral truths, and that they have them. So why do they pretend to believe the D of O? That is a long, complicated story, but a large part of what happened was back in the 1950's Marxism ran into a dead end where it couldn't win people over through normal direct political argument. And then many French radical intellectuals responded to this problem by coming up with a new two-part persuasion strategy. The first part is to try to get people who believe in capitalism to give up their views by persuading them there is no absolute truth so they would abandon their beliefs as to why the free market is the best economic philosophy. And then once the leftist had accomplished that they would change positions and persuade the now-former capitalism supporter that Marxism is the absolute best. Needless to say, this strategy has failed, but it has unfortunately left us in the position where a great many Americans say things that are nonsense and that they don't actually believe.