29 ms·
Successfully Countering Russian Electoral Interference
- olivermarks 8y agoAll first world foreign entities attempt to influence the electoral process of other nation states - wouldn't a better approach by the EU be to discuss this reality and solutions than just accusing 'Russia' of this while being holier than thou?
- lord_ring_11 8y agoSo ture. How many govts have been toppled in recent times through military action. I think surprise is that it is happening first time to west without direct military action. Last time govt was toppeled in west was French govt in WW2.
- imbokodo 8y agoActually the last time the French government was toppled was in 1958. The communists had become the largest party, and French officers, unhappy with decolonization, especially in Algeria, seized Corsica and planned to invade Metropolitan France in Operation Resurrection.
- pjc50 8y agoCarnation revolution in Portugal?
- threeseed 8y agoPlease provide evidence of this. There is widespread, documented evidence of Russian interference in the US and French elections as well as Brexit. Which when you throw in state sponsored doping demonstrates a pattern for “not following the rules”. And I don’t see why that even if what you say is true why Russian interference can’t be investigated also. Countries can do more than one thing at once.
- harshreality 8y agoYou're genuinely unaware that the U.S. has done the same thing for decades? https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/17/sunday-review/russia-isnt-the-only-one-meddling-in-elections-we-do-it-too.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/17/sunday-review/russia-isnt... One point the NYT briefly tries to make — which is all I'm addressing in the rest of this comment — is that the U.S. in (very) recent years has mainly interfered to support more democratic candidates, and oppose more authoritarian candidates. And Russia, NYT claims, interferes to support totalitarian candidates and sow chaos. Implying subtly that Trump couldn't possibly be anything other than a strong-man or chaos candidate. That there couldn't possibly be any legitimate democracy-respecting reasons to support him over Hillary (campaign donor influence apparently is perfectly democratic, when it's your candidate receiving the donations aka bribes). Trump may be many things: A nationalist, a pathological liar, in need of a fitness regime and a better diet, and a not very nice person (by most accounts)... but I have not seen any attempt by him to subvert democracy or separation of powers. I have not seen him act particularly chaotically, either. (Weren't Democrats afraid he would start a nuclear war the second he got the nuclear football?) To the extent he's a horrible president, that's the fault of the 2-party system and his catastrophically awful opposing candidate. So, The NYT basically says, yeah, the U.S. interfered in a lot of elections, but recently we've been doing it for the good of democracy. Russia, meanwhile, interferes to the detriment of democracy. First, that doesn't change the fact that it's intervention, and intervention itself is anti-democratic. If another country wants to democratically elect a strong man, that's not so good, but do other democratic countries have a right to interfere? Maybe the populations of those countries understand something intuitively about their politics that we don't, and the candidate that looks more authoritarian is really the better of two evils? Second, when we have interfered — in Libya, in Iraq, in Syria — and it turns out that the "democratic" "freedom fighter" opponents of the existing strong-man leader are terrorists or aligned with terrorists, or the country simply devolves into chaos and faction warfare in the absence of that more totalitarian leader, what then? Is interference justified to support a more freedom-loving candidate when we have no idea (or we know perfectly well, but don't care) that the country is not currently viable as a more open democracy, and needs either a totalitarian ruler or to go through the cleansing fire of a long civil war to cement the concept and importance of democracy in the people's minds?
- tomohawk 8y agoFrom the US side, it appears that interference in other countries elections is coming more from the political parties and NGOs than from the government itself, although the NGOs do attempt to get funding for these activities from the government. Consider the recent case of foreign meddling in Israel's elections. http://www.imra.org.il/story.php3?id=66198 http://www.imra.org.il/story.php3?id=66198 http://thehill.com/policy/international/236565-netanyahu-pollster-obama-role-in-election-larger-than-reported http://thehill.com/policy/international/236565-netanyahu-pol...
- EGreg 8y agoBut there is an axiom: it is OK for the US to do to others what it complains about when done to itself. Anyone see this? How is that not election interference? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nm-50K-XELY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=nm-50K-XELY
- flatfilefan 8y agoHow about successfuly proving there was any, for starters?
- justsomedude43 8y agoYou're stepping on some toes here.
- Viliam1234 8y agoAlso, why does everyone blindly believe that a country called Russia even exists? Wake up, sheeple! /s
- paulgb 8y agoI'll play. Which of these claims do you think haven't been sufficiently demonstrated? 1. There was social media interference in the 2016 US elections through the spreading of propaganda on social media. 2. Some of that campaign originated (geographically) from Russia. 3. The Kremlin (whether or not through the Internet Research Agency) was behind some of this propaganda. Separately, I'm curious whether you believe: 4. The Kremlin is involved in social media-based election interference in countries other than the USA.
- sigfubar 8y agoI’m a Russian citizen living in the US, and here’s what I think is true. 1. Social media was constructed for all sorts of parties to influence the American consumer as a set of bought & sold “audiences” (in adtech speak). Some of these audiences are defined using political parameters. Some advertisers targeting these audiences via social media are politically motivated. The whole thing - all of social media - is a form in interference in the way people think. 2. Some advertisers are based in Russia. Most are not. Anyone can buy ads targeting a specific audience on any number of platforms. 3. I’m surprised they bothered to create a shell org to do this. Russia - like many other countries - has vested interests in US policy. Consider this a form of lobbying: just like American corporations go to Washington in order to lobby (“have undue influence over”) elected officials, so do countries “lobby” the American electorate come election time, because the public is seen as susceptible to such influence. In fact America even built platforms for this: social media. 4. Probably, but so is the US, and everyone else. I cannot believe Americans are so upset about something they themselves made possible.
- dontyouremember 8y agoIronic that many of the comments here are https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- amai 8y agoThis was probably the most effective countermeasure: "Knowing that they would be hacked, the campaign forged emails and fake documents themselves to confuse the hackers with irrelevant and even deliberately ludicrous information. By placing false flags, the campaign wished to inundate, confuse, and impede the work of the hackers with false information and slow them down. The campaign’s strategy of “counter-retaliation for phishing attempts”11 is known as cyber or digital blurring. It worked by turning the burden-of-proof tables on the hackers. The Macron campaign staff did not have to explain potentially compromising information contained in the Macron Leaks; rather, the hackers had to justify why they stole and leaked information that seemed, at best, useless and, at worst, false or misleading. The whole thing made the population doubt the authenticity of any of the leaked material."