3 ms·
Sounds like you want a license where you get to dictate exactly how any downstream user reuses your software, down to the details of the packaging, and prohibit
by _delirium 16y ago
Sounds like you want a license where you get to dictate exactly how any downstream user reuses your software, down to the details of the packaging, and prohibit modifications/forks/removals/etc.? But that's not really an open-source license at all, then.
The whole point of open-source software is that I can take a thing, decide that I only want 50% of it, rip out the other 50%, add on a bunch of new stuff, totally change some of the remaining stuff, use it for a new purpose, package it in a new way, undo a decision the maintainer made that I disagree with, etc. If you don't like people having that freedom, open-source just doesn't seem like the way to go. It sounds like you want a "freeware for verbatim distribution" proprietary-but-no-cost license.
- davidw 16y ago> dictate exactly how any downstream user reuses your software I agree with your post. It's also worth pointing out that if someone abandons open source licensing, one thing I'd put in my licenses - way before we talk about fiddling with the path layout and such - is that the software can't be used by people I find reprehensible: neonazis, repressive governments, and so on and so forth. Of course, I prefer freedom to that kind of licensing, so I just live with the knowledge that horrible people may use things I wrote.
- avar 16y agoThe people you harm by restricting neo-nazis from using your software aren't neo-nazis, but everyone else who has to pay for lawyer time to review your custom license before they can use it. Or what's more likely: aren't going to use it at all once they see what sort of license you have.
- davidw 16y agoNot to mention that actual neonazis will probably not give a great deal of thought to violating said license, meaning you'd have to have a way to monitor usage, and then go to court to stop them. All in all, a hassle that's not worth it.
- btilly 16y agoActually it is OK to use a license that says that if you change X, Y, and Z then you can't name it Foo and can't say it is written by Bar. I think that such a license would fit Zed's needs perfectly. Particularly if his restrictions were mild enough that nobody minded following them.
- cmsj 16y agoFirefox would be an obvious example of that. All that happens is that Debian will rename the package and ship it anyway, and users lose even more than they did before. Good job! ;)