5 ms·
One should add that this didn't happen with the old NASA in Alabama under the germans. This only started with LBJ ditching the Apollo team, the liquid rockets,
by rurban 8y ago
One should add that this didn't happen with the old NASA in Alabama under the germans.
This only started with LBJ ditching the Apollo team, the liquid rockets, and splitting up NASA into Houston and California under US management. It went downhill since then.
The NASA never really was about space travel, because then they would have kept the Apollo tech and liquid rockets. But military needed only solid fuel rockets so they switched and developed the shuttle. And now they have no proper tech anymore at all.
- Herodotus38 8y agoI'm not sure why you are being downvoted. I'll admit I've never heard this opinion before but I'm interested in learning more. Do you have any links or books that go into more detail?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bryananderson 8y agoThis is a wholly inaccurate picture of NASA’s organization then and now. The centers in Alabama, California, and Houston were all subsidiaries of NASA headquarters in Washington, and remain so today. Control was never held by the Alabama center, nor was it transferred to any of the other field centers. Von Braun was the director of Marshall (the Alabama center) throughout the Space Race until well after LBJ.
- Herodotus38 8y agoThanks, I thought the OP's post was odd, as I'd never heard of Alabama being the center, and I've been more interested in spaceflight for the last 4 years. I don't have enough historical knowledge in this area to definitively rule out what was posted, and it seemed plausible that there was tension between solid and liquid development. I am currently readin Von Braun's 'Space Frontiers' and enjoy it. Any recommendations for a next book about the history of US rocketry?
- bryananderson 8y agoAndrew Chaikin’s ‘A Man on the Moon’ is a wonderful history of the Space Race.
- Herodotus38 8y agoThank you
- rurban 8y agoLaughable. Washington gave all control to Von Braun after the Sputnik desaster, and Von Braun delivered dramatically. They only cut his budget, because Von Braun wanted to fly humans to Mars, and Washington wanted intercontinental rockets with nuclear payloads only. LBJ did the first dramatic cuts by favoring the Californian solid rocket development and moved control away from Alabama to the new Houston site. And then Nixon killed it completely and went with the Shuttle program, out of Von Braun hands.
- mcguire 8y agoYes and no. Yes, NASA HQ is in Washington and always has been. On the other hand, the centers have always had a lot of autonomy; moreso in the past, and the fight to coalesce overlapping facilities is messy. (Source: Work for the NASA Enterprise Applications Competency Center (yes, that's a thing) and get to see the sausage being made.) JPL is one fun example. It's really only loosly associated with the rest of NASA. And it does most of the unmanned, science flight programs, using DOD launch vehicles. That goes back to the early days of NASA following Sputnik and the Explorer I vs von Braun/MSFC/Alabama teams. MSFC has been the center of launch system development since, for the manned side of things. And the shuttle, in retrospect, seems not to have been a great idea. Tl;dr: To paraphrase Ghandi, NASA organization might be a really good idea.