7 ms·
How 2,000 Servers Broke the Enigma Code in 13 Minutes
- inetsee 8y agoThe one line from the article that resonated the most with me was this one: "What would Alan Turing be able to do nowadays if he had the current computing power and all the development around AI?"
- wry_discontent 8y agoWhere would we be if computer programming wasn't recreating nearly identical CRUD apps and desperately figuring out how to make people on the internet click on more ads?
- red75prime 8y agoThat's a sufficiently different alternative universe, where people don't take certain avenues of money making. Depending on the differences, it could be that there's no programming at all.
- bartread 8y agoWhat really blows my mind is how overcomplicated so many organisations manage to make these CRUD apps by bolting together as many technologies as humanly possible. I'm sure it's probably boredom that drives people to it, but for me the frustration that results from having to work on these bloated and overcomplicated systems is worse, and I think strongly damaging to businesses. My own impression, which has only grown stronger with the passage of years, is that if you did the totally necessary CRUD stuff as simply as possible, that would open up opportunities to tech-enable businesses in much more interesting and profitable ways. But, of course, that would involve delaying gratification, and often doesn't play to the prevailing politics. Interesting software jobs do exist but, boy, do you have to hunt for them.
- diroussel 8y agoThat is a very narrow view of what you can do with computer programming. What about embedded software in pace makers than runs inside peoples hearts. The vast simulators that can simulate each collision within the Large Hadron Collider then compare the results of the donation to the results of the experiment. What about getting you paid on time. Or allowing a person to make a contactless payment in another country. The world is awash with interesting applications of intention technology.
- Sangermaine 8y agoOr the more tragic and infuriating question: "What would current computing be like if Alan Turing hadn't been driven to suicide?"
- Animats 8y agoProbably like the IBM 600 series of business computers. One step at a time. IBM 601 (1936) - mechanical multiplication, punched card I/O IBM 602 (1946) - mechanical multiply and divide IBM 603 (1946) - first commercial electronic arithmetic, a vacuum tube-based 602 IBM 604 (1948) - Next-gen 603, a limited computer programmed with a plugboard board IBM 605 (1949) - a bigger 604 IBM CPC (1949) - An IBM 605 with peripherals - card reader, card punch, memory units, printer. IBM 607 (1953) - The CPC in more compact packaging with more memory. IBM 650 (1953) - First real computer in this series. First mass-produced computer. Drum main memory. First disks. Knuth learned on one of those. IBM 1401 (1957) - Transistorized, core memory computer. Not much memory, but good tape drives. Mass produced. This was cost-effective computing for business. There was other stuff going on in parallel, but most of it was military-funded. These machines ran business and had to pay. The big problem was memory cost. Everybody knew more memory would make more things possible, but memory was a million dollars a megabyte well into the 1960s.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThis refers to a PR event that DigitalOcean participated in back in early December 2017, < https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171201005267/en/DigitalOcean%C2%A0-cracked-Enigma-Code-record-time%21 https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171201005267/en/Dig... >. By the sound of this article, it makes me suspect DigitalOcean doesn’t really do any machine learning (here they paid for a marketing piece 7 months later?). Not that they need to: they are a great cloud provider. I wonder why they need to do this for marketing. If the goal is to say, look how we used 1-click for this PR fluff, will that really be attractive to the sort of enterprise ML customers who would possibly care? And why 7 months later?
- cornholio 8y ago> Within half a day, DigitalOcean had hydrated the 1,000 droplets used in the testing phase. What, the proprietary cloud technologies are now re-writing the English vocabulary for just an itsy bit of extra vendor lock-in? I find this double plus hydrating.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoMajor misnomer. It sounds like a bunch of cloud servers were used to brute-force enigma, and then possible "solutions" were checked as valid german by an AI. The AI didn't break the code. Also it probably would be trivial to write a non-ai that detects valid german (e.g. is every word german?). False positives would be easy to filter out.
- femto113 8y agoThis 13 minutes on 1000 computers number is really failing to impress me. Consider that someone on Quora calculated > the sum total of all the computing power produced by all of the Bombes during the entire war is about the same computing power used by one iPhone to play back 10 seconds of YouTube https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-computing-capacity-of-Alan-Turings-machine-called-Bombe-that-deciphered-the-Enigma https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-computing-capacity-of-Ala...
- hk__2 8y ago> Modern AI Breaks German Enigma Code in 13 Minutes Please use the original title: "How 2,000 Droplets Broke the Enigma Code in 13 Minutes". "Modern AI" has very little to do with the performance here. As the article states, the team worked 4 weeks and had 2,000 machines to run their code. Even brute-forcing would give you a performance close to that. Quoting from the article: > So for the AI to shine, we actually use 2,000 minions that do the tedious work. Everybody praises AI, but it's actually the minions that do the 99% of work. Life, right?
- dang 8y agoOk, we'll use that title except with an English word replacing the brand name.
- stereo 8y agoIt sounds like they just trained a bayesian filter like langdetect to recognise simple German. A smarter training corpus would have been decrypted Enigma messages! A decrypted enigma message looks like this: BOOTKLARXBEIJSCHNOORBETWAZWOSIBENXNOVXSECHSNULCBMXPROVIANTBISZWONULXDEZXBENOETIGEGLMESERYNOCHVIEFKLHRXSTEHEMARQUBRUNOBRUNFZWOFUHFXLAGWWIEJKCHAEFERJXNNTWWWFUNFYEINSFUNFMBSTEIGENDYGUTESIWXDVVVJRASCH Plaintext with word divisions, and with garbled letters corrected: BOOT KLAR X BEI J SCHNOOR J ETWA ZWO SIBEN X NOV X SECHS NUL CBM X PROVIANT BIS ZWO NUL X DEZ X BENOETIGE GLAESER Y NOCH VIER KLAR X STEHE MARQU BRUNO BRUNO ZWO FUNF X LAGE WIE J SCHAEFER J X NNN WWW FUNF Y EINS FUNF MB STEIGEND Y GUTE SICHT VVV J RASCH Formatted German plaintext: Boot klar. Bei “Schnoor” etwa 27. Nov. 60 cbm. Proviant bis 20 Dez. Benötige Gläser, noch 4 klar. Stehe Marqu. BB 25. Lage wie “Schaefer”. NW 5, 15 mb steigend, gute Sicht. Von “Rasch”. English translation (words in square brackets added to make the meaning more clear): Boat clear. [Will rendezvous] at Schnoor about 27 November. 60 cubic meters [fuel oil remaining], provisions [sufficient] until 20 December. Need binoculars; [only] four now serviceable. Am at naval square BB 25. Situation like Schaefer’s. [Wind] northwest [force] 5, [atmospheric pressure] 15 millibars rising, good visibility. From Rasch.
- rixrax 8y agoThere are still some (correction: at least one) unbroken Enigma message(s) from WWII around[1][2]. Would be intriguing see how this would fare on them. [1] https://enigma.hoerenberg.com/index.php?cat=Unbroken https://enigma.hoerenberg.com/index.php?cat=Unbroken [2] http://www.bytereef.org/m4_project.html http://www.bytereef.org/m4_project.html