7 ms·
Botg site admin "The hash doesn't match because the filename doesn't match." A fully descriptive answer is that they don't have a checksum for the bundled pack
by michaelmrose 8y ago
Botg site admin
"The hash doesn't match because the filename doesn't match."
A fully descriptive answer is that they don't have a checksum for the bundled package but botg doesn't want to say this.
" Dangerously ignorant user. Not matching filename = the checksum is NOT for that file. Checksums can only be provided for the non-bundled packages, because they're static. Bundled installers are not."
Dangerously ignorant person here what they are actually saying is that they have no way on earth to be sure what's even IN the bundled packages nor what it will do to the users computer.
They have decided that tricking people into downloading malware is a reasonable alternative to charging money for their software or soliciting donations.
Its truly amazing to me that installing windows software is still like this.
The obvious and immediate solution is to abandon vendors who behave like this. This is challenging because you have to track the reputation of each individual vendor and users have proven unable to even consistently download the software from the right page let alone judge individuals vendors track record.
The long term solution is to get off the platform.
- ksk 8y agoVendors who have partaken in the "bundled crapware" model of distribution - Google, Amazon, Yahoo, Microsoft, Adobe, Oracle, etc, etc. >They have decided that tricking people into downloading malware is a reasonable alternative to charging money for their software or soliciting donations. If you would be so kind enough as to show them how to make money perhaps they'll stop doing it. >Its truly amazing to me that installing windows software is still like this. Eh? Which OS platform are you using that does not allow a user to execute binaries?
- michaelmrose 8y agoI would rather they go out of business if they can't figure out another way to make money. You CAN install binaries on other platforms but on for example linux distros their is a curated platform of packages where you can get most/all software. The fact that this is the default way to install software and regular users don't need to look beyond the official repos is why installing software on linux isn't this kind of shit show.
- ksk 8y agoWell, I do think there is some hypocrisy on the part of people (including myself) enjoying free software and services, when the revenue of those is generated by unaware people clicking on ads or accidentally installing crapware. >You CAN install binaries on other platforms but on for example linux distros their is a curated platform of packages where you can get most/all software. Sure, but things often work better when you pay people upfront rather than get something for free and let them fend for themselves. In the case of Linux packaging, there is no mechanism for monetization or advertising, so the point doesn't come up. >The fact that this is the default way to install software and regular users don't need to look beyond the official repos is why installing software on linux isn't this kind of shit show. I'd use Linux if it had the software that I want to use. So a bit of apples-oranges here...
- code_duck 8y ago"things often work better when you pay people upfront rather than get something for free and let them fend for themselves"... Whoah, for a second I thought this was 1999.
- ksk 8y agoI guess I must have fallen into a time machine since I just purchased Photoshop last month.
- code_duck 8y agoThat would be which logical fallacy? Something where you take something I said to a nonsensical extreme? I certainly never asserted that people did not pay for software. My point is that free software is very proven as a development, distribution, whatever method by now.
- ksk 8y ago>My point is that free software is very proven as a development, distribution, whatever method by now. Yes, it is indeed proven that when you pay people to develop software, it works great. (Linux, FF, Chrome, Photoshop, Windows, etc, etc). The license doesn't seem to make much of a difference. When you don't - (your typical freeware on download.com) - they have to figure out a revenue stream after the fact, and the choices they end up making cause them to be on the front page of HN where people line up to call them "scum". Obviously this is not about hobbyist/part-time developers with a github repo, who are already getting paid through an external job, etc.
- Joeri 8y agoI got tricked into installing adware as part of a java install, and took me many hours to get it back off my system. I don’t get why microsoft isn’t pushing all these vendors really hard to distribute through the windows store. The windows store is a graveyard compared to the mac app store, despite having a head start and a bigger target audience, and it’s basically impossible to use windows without sideloading apps. Microsoft is pushing windows S at people, where you can’t sideload software, but the windows store just isn’t ready for that and all it will do is push people to the mac when they inevitably have a bad experience.
- ksk 8y agoBecause nobody really wants to give the AppStore 30% of their revenue. Having it be a percentage of the revenue instead of just a flat fee means its just a money-grab IMHO. Ironically Apple is arguing in court that Qualcomm is doing the same thing to them (charging a percentage based on retail pricing) and that the price is unfair.
- NiveaGeForce 8y agoVery soon it won't be 30% anymore. https://blogs.windows.com/buildingapps/2018/05/07/a-new-microsoft-store-revenue-share-is-coming/ https://blogs.windows.com/buildingapps/2018/05/07/a-new-micr...
- ksk 8y ago:o Nice..
- 9935c101ab17a66 8y agolol you're out here arguing that the people who are (without FULLY disclosing it) bundling malware that downloads and compiles DATs/unsigned binaries from anon domains are in the right, but you have a problem with Apple's revenue model for the App Store?
- ksk 8y ago
- ourmandave 8y agoIts truly amazing to me that installing windows software is still like this. You think this is bad, you should try the Windows 10 auto updater. Disclaimer: It's broken on my brand new PC and no helpful on-line fix has worked so far. So I might hold hate in my heart.
- teraflop 8y agoSimilar experience here; Windows Update has been completely broken since shortly after I upgraded from Win7 to Win10. It tries to update -- it downloads several GB of patches, reboots and spends about 20 minutes installing -- then it tells me something along the lines of my system being "incompatible" with Windows (I forget the details, it's been a while) and rolls everything back. Every six months or so I let it try again, in vain hope that the latest version will have fixed the problem. At some point I should get around to doing a clean reinstall, but that means taking the risk that my old Win7 product key would no longer validate.
- vbezhenar 8y agoRisk should be minimal. If you installed Windows 10 and it's activated, it should work after reinstall, you don't even need to type product key, MS servers remember that your hardware is authorized to run Windows 10.
- dvlsg 8y agoHey, mine too! I actually had that, reformatted, it was fixed for a while, and it's back to doing it again. The worst part is when windows will start ignoring my request to delay updates to the weekend, and will begin restarting my computer during the week whenever I walk away from it for too long.
- ourmandave 8y agoFlash backs to the Win XP restart dialog that popped up every 20 minutes until you couldn't take it anymore.
- gaius 8y agoThe long term solution is to get off the platform. Never any malware on other platforms? Do you not remember Sourceforge? And let’s not forget that so much Linux software installs these days via curl|sh...
- techntoke 8y agoThat's why I use my distro's package manager and review external scripts before running them.
- gaius 8y agoSame here. PyPI and NPM are the Wild West too. Github makes no effort to combat typosquatting either. People in glasshouses shouldn’t throw stones...
- loganabbott 8y agoFYI the SourceForge version of FileZilla is clean, and has been since 2016. The official FileZilla installer has been doing this for some time now though. In case people don’t know, a lot has changed at SourceForge since my company acquired them in 2016. All projects are scanned for malware. We covered the improvements again here https://sourceforge.net/blog/brief-history-sourceforge-look-to-future/ https://sourceforge.net/blog/brief-history-sourceforge-look-...
- morganvachon 8y agoThat is awesome and I'm glad you are working to clean up the Sourceforge reputation. However, the issue (at least for me) is one of shattered trust. Even though you can affirm the Filezilla downloads you host don't have malicious payloads in the installer, I no longer trust the creator of Filezilla. If he's scummy enough to fill up his "bundled" installer with known malware and viruses, and then lie to his users about it on his forum, he's scummy enough to put something potentially harmful in the program itself. It would be trivial to integrate a hidden Monero or other coin miner in the source of the main Filezilla program that only runs when the program itself is running. I know I often leave my FTP going overnight for uploading big files (I have really fast downstream but painfully slow upstream) and that's a lot of time for my machine to be surreptitiously mining for someone else. Multiply that by the hundred of thousands if not millions of Filezilla users across all platforms, and you have the potential for a ton of illicitly gained virtual money at your users' expense.
- belorn 8y agoGetting off platforms is usually quite hard with most trying to be as sticky as possible. The common reason why people tend to stick to Windows is games, even if the situation has gotten better. Personally I have come to the conclusion that the best solution is virtual machines with a linux base system. Put every game that is sticky to windows into its own little container and just have hardware passed through. That way every form of sticky platform only exist in a small pocket of virtual space. The tricky part is getting all this working as smoothly as if it was just one system that just happen to have really good sandboxing for untrustworthy platforms.
- jimnotgym 8y ago> The common reason why people tend to stick to Windows is games For home users perhaps. Enterprise users are often locked into ERP clients, for instance, that are Windows only. But the real killer reason enterprises use Windows is Active Directory. Simple GUI SSO and policy based management. For instance I could have a white-list that didn't have this adware on it and could apply it by group-policy...
- Fnoord 8y agoActive Directory is just a fancy name for LDAP, Kerberos, and DNS (often in combination with CIFS). There's no reason why you cannot use an equiv in a partly or pure Linux/UNIX environment. And indeed, there are many partly Linux/UNIX environments where the servers are running on Linux/UNIX yet the clients are running on Windows. The killer feature of Windows is that people are used to running it as desktop, meaning a less steep learning curve. Another one to add to the list of features is Exchange, but even that has *NIX alternatives.
- Conan_Kudo 8y agoI've found that FreeIPA tends to be a fantastic replacement: https://www.freeipa.org/ https://www.freeipa.org/ If you're using Red Hat/Fedora GNOME desktops, you can pair that with Fleet Commander to set up desktop policy: https://fleet-commander.org/ https://fleet-commander.org/ At some point soon, I expect it to work for SUSE and Mageia systems, too. I currently run this on a Fedora Server setup to pair with some Fedora Workstations I manage.
- NiveaGeForce 8y ago> Its truly amazing to me that installing windows software is still like this It doesn't have to be that way, since there is a Windows/Microsoft Store since plenty of years now. But then you have gamers and game devs spreading FUD about UWP and the the MS Store, while they praise 3rd party platforms like Steam and GoG that actively refuse UWP apps in their store, while allowing Spyware like this. https://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/8pud8b/psa_red_shell_spyware_holy_potatoes_were_in_space/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/8pud8b/psa_red_shell... Yet, nobody dares to hold those platforms responsible. https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/8sg294/16_studios_removing_alleged_spyware_from_pc_games/e0zcl5y/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/8sg294/16_studios_re... > The long term solution is to get off the platform. No, the long term solution is to embrace the MS Store, or at the very least modern platforms like WinRT/UWP that would prevent most types of malware attacks. Why do we still accept the violation of the principle of least privilege in this day and age?
- codedokode 8y agoMicrosoft itself is collecting a lot of telemetry even in Basic configuration [1], for example, if you use UAC (privileges elevation popup) they collect "the full command line arguments being used to elevate.". Also they collect a lot of hardware identifiers (including IMEI - unique phone identifier that allows to track it) so later they can reliably prove that some user was using this computer at this time. What a nice feature. They also collect information on files that are " part of an app and either have a block in the compatibility database or are part of an anti-virus program.". How can we trust Microsoft after this? [1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy/basic-level-windows-diagnostic-events-and-fields https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy/basic-level...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NiveaGeForce 8y agoDo you rather trust arbitrary 3rd party Win32 apps, that have free reign to crawl your whole user profile and mess with the integrity of your system? If you're already on Windows 10, at the very least embrace UWP to get some control over your privacy.
- tytytytytytytyt 8y agoWhy can't someone just check the digital signature like he says?
- codedokode 8y agoI think the long term solution would be to forbid deceiving users by software vendors. Users should know exactly what they are paying with. Now the vendors who sell software that doesn't have hidden functionality lose competition to such "free" products monetized with adware, data collection or other shady behaviours. It is easy to see in mobile game market.
- ComodoHacker 8y ago>they don't have a checksum for the bundled package but botg doesn't want to say this Well, it shouldn't really be called "bundled". It's more a "drive-by download". What is bundled is only a downloader (so the checksum remains the same). And it offers and downloads what the other party sees more profitable today. In this sense they really don't know what they bundle.
- kodablah 8y ago> The long term solution is to get off the platform. Ug. Running untrusted executables on any platform can be trouble. The problem is that by blaming the platform, people keep putting the onus on these OS's, distros, etc to build walls around carefully curated gardens. Gotta take the good with the bad. Either you accept that people can run untrusted executables or you give up the flexibility to build/use/distribute untrusted executables yourself. Sadly it seems as devs grow into larger companies and prefer the latter, they forget their indie beginnings enabled by the former. "What's $100?" they say. "Getting a cert is easy" they say. "If you aren't building anything dangerous, why do you have a problem with curation?" they say. The same anti-freedom arguments are always there in the name of safety. If you downloaded untrusted Filezilla and executed it raw on any platform it could be an issue. If users required Filezilla to be distributed in the Windows app store, it could be less of an issue. One could argue the fact that installing Windows software is sometimes still like this is because of the lack of restrictions against it. But as users keep complaining and devs stay silent, all platforms including Windows will continue to reduce liberty in the name of safety and you'll feel better.
- code_duck 8y agoIt sounds like you have a lot more experience with windows than other platforms. Many who have mainly used windows haven't experienced what typical software installation is like on systems like Linux. One hardly ever needs to run on trusted executables, for any reason. If you do, they come from one or two trusted sources, not one of hundreds of private websites. That is just not how Linux software is distributed. It doesn't abridge freedom, either - if you want to run I trusted executables, nothing is trying to stop you, either. Then, if you do have an executable to install from, the installation process is more likely to be one command run in a terminal then a GUI 'wizard' that takes 10 minutes, frequent attention and 20 clicks, and tries to convince/trick you to install a bunch of other software.
- kodablah 8y agoMy experience ranges across platforms which is why I call out this ridiculous bias when I see it, especially when it uses dumb examples like Filezilla to represent the whole. Look at the other options for Filezilla downloads. The default Mac one is the same bundled crap from the same source. The Linux one is from the same source too. Of course I would be unreasonable to criticize the other platforms if the forum post was about those instead. > One hardly ever needs to run on trusted executables, for any reason. If you do, they come from one or two trusted sources, not one of hundreds of private websites That's just not true if you want up to date software. I can list a ton of software to the contrary and lots of installing that includes just extracting tarballs, or installing their deb/rpm you download, or if they use the distro package manager, they just have you add their server and cert. > GUI 'wizard' that takes 10 minutes, frequent attention and 20 clicks Well if you're just gonna give false impressions with hyperbole, a rational discussion can't be had. Regardless, the issues with installation are primarily the choice of the devs, not the OS. These days they more look like the installation of Nodejs, Go, PgAdmin, VSCode, etc (i.e. minimal MSI's or just zip extracts) than complicated adware of yore. That this is not clear and you think 10 minute wizards with 20 clicks is normal makes it seem like you are not familiar with the platforms you talk about.
- mirimir 8y agoWell, botg does come pretty close to admitting that: #9 Post by botg » 2018-01-05 09:11 The connections are for fetching offers and, if the user accepts the offer, the offered file. What the file is for is written in the offer text. The network requests to fetch offers are done only after the user has agreed to it by accepting the privacy policy. Right, the user has agreed to install some random thing. #10 Post by TigheW » 2018-01-05 16:55 Sorry man, this isn't "bundled software that people want" and no amount of repeating it will make it true. This is a malware downloader bundled with your software and hosted on your page and you're intentionally misleading the users who are here directly asking you if it's safe to run this bundle on their machines. ... Damn.
- duxup 8y ago>This is challenging because you have to track the reputation of each individual vendor and users have proven unable to even consistently download the software from the right page let alone judge individuals vendors track record. There was a pattern where articles about nasty android apps would always include some idiotic line about "Security experts say do not install apps you don't trust." Who the hell knows anything about the apps they even trust, for all you know they sold out to malware companies yesterday.... there's no way to know. Let alone that would also mean you never try any new software... I HATE that line.
- mkonecny 8y agoHashes never take the filename into account anyway. He knows this, and is trying to throw users off track.