4 ms·
>The status quo comes at great cost — high rents paid to financial intermediary institutions along with other various and protected oligarchies. So far so good
by andrepd 8y ago
>The status quo comes at great cost — high rents paid to financial intermediary institutions along with other various and protected oligarchies.
So far so good.
>However, it also provides benefits in the form of public goods.
Hmm.
>It generates and sustains core functions of the broader state and economy such as tools to capture tax revenues, prevent money laundering and terrorism financing, capacity to control the money supply, protect consumers and investors, and ensure market integrity and even (a degree of) financial stability.
Tools to capture tax revenue, prevent money laundering, and prevent terrorist financing? I thought tax evasion and money laundering were some of the services they offered! Protect consumers and investors? Secure financial stability? What?? Did everybody forget about 2008 already? A small elite set of people KNOWINGLY wrecked the world economy, calculatedly corrupted our political, regulatory, and academic bodies to ensure no responsibility ever come to them, let alone demands of repayment, flipped the incentives around to become fabulously rich and rewarded for driving their companies into the ground and ruining their clients, got paid to lie and deceive, to give lectures and papers and audits saying everything was a-OK, to lie to clients about the junk they were peddling, to take regulatory roles and stand aside... If you want to see it this way, doubtless millions of excess deaths are attributable to their actions. Make no mistake, if they could get away with it they would murder your entire family in cold blood for a hundred bucks.
The current financial/banking scheme can very well go fuck itself. It's difficult to do worse than this; it's a broken in almost every way, except in securing power and vast wealth to a select group of people. Note, I'm not saying blockchain will surely bring about anything better.
- giantsloth 8y agoThe crisis was largely due in part to deregulation and private companies getting kick backs for their ratings. Crypto currency is mostly unregulated and rated on a private market. Also, there is a small elite group of people who own most of the crypto currency, which very quickly and easily could result in market manipulation at the expense of small holders. While your anger is understandable and banks are indeed criminal, cryptocoins are just as susceptible to criminal behavior as any other market place and even more so do to the lack of regulation. And I’d just like to note that major banks like Goldman are saying that btc is bullshit while quietly buying a massive stake in it. So, the fact is, the banks will get involved if it’s worth money and they will manipulate the market, so we will be right back where we started.
- hndamien 8y agoWith one important difference. There will be no QE ever.
- UncleEntity 8y agoUnless you rename QE to something like "hard fork". In order to preserve the integrity of the blockchain the following actions must be taken...
- hndamien 8y agoExcept that users are in control.
- lokedhs 8y agoRegardless of whether the banks deserved to fall after 2008 or not, I'm struggling to of any way in which things would have been different with cryptocurrencies. Do you seriously think that one wouldn't be able to construct fraudulent financial instruments on top of cryptocurrencies just like you can with the regular financial system? If you think that there is a difference in this regard I recommend you investigate how these financial instruments were actually constructed.
- ozim 8y agoNot that long ago there was this article posted on HN: https://hacked.com/last-years-crypto-boom-was-fixed-researchers/ https://hacked.com/last-years-crypto-boom-was-fixed-research...
- lifty 8y agoPerhaps one fundamental difference between the normal financial system and the more popular cryptocurrencies is in the way the money supply is managed. In the traditional system money becomes very cheap in specific periods, coincidentally or not right before major crisis events, which can act as gas on fire. In contrast, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or Ethereum have a more restrained issuance schedule, which some people or schools of economic thought argue that can lead to better emergent outcomes in the overall economy, avoid the boom and bust cycle. But of course, you can still build financial tricks based on them, but they might not have the same effect on the overall economy.
- gmueckl 8y agoNo. I could go and found a bitcoin bank in which anyone can open an account. The catch? The bank runs a single wallet to back all accounts. The only promise made by the bank is that if you deposit X bitcoins, you'll get X bitcoins back when you request to withdraw them. I'll also allow you instant transfers between the accounts. They are off the blockchain, managed only in the bank's database, so these transactions can be arbitrarily fast. If the wallet accumulates enough bitcoins so that it exceeds the normal volume of deposits and withdrawals, I'll take the rest and put them to work. Maybe buy shares in companies or so. I'll keep the earnings of these investments. If I make a loss, I'll have to recover the loss somehow. That's the risk I take. At that point, I'd have created virtual bitcoins in the market. And who would be stopping me?
- nl 8y agobecome fabulously rich and rewarded for driving their companies into the ground and ruining their clients, got paid to lie and deceive, to give lectures and papers and audits saying everything was a-OK, to lie to clients about the junk they were peddling, to take regulatory roles and stand aside. Have you seen what many ICOs are like?