6 ms·
Not to nitpick, but I'm not sure the nature of time is so indisputably the greatest remaining mystery. The nature of consciousness, life, and death can all cer
by pmoriarty 8y ago
Not to nitpick, but I'm not sure the nature of time is so indisputably the greatest remaining mystery.
The nature of consciousness, life, and death can all certainly give it a run for its money.
Incidentally, would anyone happen to have a direct link to a version of this article that could be read without enabling javascript?
- imglorp 8y agoAlso the origin of the universe, why it's accelerating its expansion, how are gravity and quantum phenomena reconciled and how do they work.... I'd say it's a great time to be alive and there's no shortage of important questions!
- everdev 8y ago"Nature of existence" probably encapsulates all of those ideas including time as time seems to be required for a creation/destruction type event.
- simondedalus 8y agonature of consciousness is the biggest one IMO, precisely because it doesn't appear to be captured by "nature of existence." we have good physical/mathematical models on hand re: causation, such that we can at least start hypothesizing about what change is, where the universe came from, what if anything differentiates life from other motion, etc. but consciousness is so categorically different that we can't even start. "well, brains are made up of cells and further of particles, and electricity works this way and here's some results from information theory and [UTTER MAGICAL WALL / ABYSSAL GAP] then there's the subjective experience of consciousness and will. and damnit we don't have anything like a logical or explanatory connection between these two sides, but for 'well, if i destroy 'someone else's' (??? what's this possessive in our fundamental terms???) body in the right way, it stops acting as if it's conscious like me, and also my own consciousness (which i can't describe with any specificity) changes when i do weird physical things involving drugs, injury, nutrition, um... and attitudes seem to matter, and there's definitely a subconscious, i guess, and...'..."
- perl4ever 8y agoIf you accept that other people are conscious like yourself, it seems like you have accepted the physical origin of consciousness. If you don't accept that the subjective experience of consciousness is just a product of physical events, then how do you avoid viewing yourself as the only conscious entity? You can be a solipsist or not, but you can't have it both ways. Experiencing thoughts from outside yourself is a common experience, but it's generally considered a delusion.
- simondedalus 8y agothere's a gulf as big as the ocean between acceptance and explanation. we have good reason to assume that consciousness (whatever it is) depends on the physical. great, but what is it?
- perl4ever 8y agoI wasn't taking sides on whether it's physical or not, so I wouldn't particularly agree with your statement. I'm only trying to say that if you don't accept that consciousness is physical, you aren't accepting the symmetry between you and other minds, and can't reason from the assumption they have the same experience. Once you contradict the known fact that you experience your own thoughts and not others, you descend into incoherence. It seems to me kind of like the issues people have with quantum weirdness. People are accustomed to assuming they know things for the sake of argument, but assuming you know the unknowable can sabotage your reasoning.
- beesmum 8y agoWhile I think it's an interesting argument, I don't agree that accepting that some other being than me can be conscious leads to having to accept the physical origin of consciousness a priori. If you look at Buddhism or any esoteric system, they essentially posit that consciousness is a unified field from which everything manifests, like light refracted through an (infinitely) complex array of lens. The spots of light where the light terminates look separate, but if you look at where the source of the light enters the lens, it all comes from a single source. The experience of having a separate consciousness and a body or mind or thoughts that I identify as me or an I that is not you or that car or that tree is essentially just an illusion because I don't have the awareness to be conscious of that unity. Just because something appears to be separate from one perspective doesn't mean that it's separate in reality, it's just that I experience it as separate due to my limited perspective. Consciousness is an experiential vehicle by nature. It doesn't slot into the scientific method all that well no matter how we try to cram it in.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoTime is a convenient measure of relative energy. (Just as the length of a king's ulna once defined distance.) IMO, 'creation/destruction' is another convenient idea, invented because our minds are boggled by 'eternity'.
- jfaucett 8y agoYes. For me the greatest remaining mysteries are more in this order. 1. Nature of Life (we are still nowhere near understanding how it arose or how living organisms work in all their intricate detail). 2. Nature of Consciousness - what is consciousness, how can living matter instantiate it, how can we quantify it, etc? 3. Origin of the Universe 4. Why do we seem so alone in the Universe? 5. Resolving Quantum Mechanics / Gravity 6. Understanding Time
- whatshisface 8y agoI would bump the origin of the universe to the top, because no matter what universe-generating physics you come up with I can always ask, "but what set things up to work that way?" I'd also put consciousness up there, because it's fundamentally distinct from measurable things. Consciousness and the origin of the universe get place 0, and the others all get place 1 because they're solvable but we don't know in which order.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"I would bump the origin of the universe to the top, because no matter what universe-generating physics you come up with I can always ask, "but what set things up to work that way?"" Except that it might not be possible to get outside of consciousness to have any testable way of explaining what set it up to be that way. It seems that we are hard-limited by our consciousness, and have no way of going outside of it to peek at "the universe" beyond.
- redial 8y ago> I'd also put consciousness up there, because it's fundamentally distinct from measurable things. No one knows that it is not measurable. Is love measurable? is hunger? happiness? they seem to be as measurable as consciousness, that is to say we can at least measure them in binary as either present or not.
- andrepd 8y agoHow do you know everyone else is not a "p-zombie", indistinguishable in any external way from a human such as yourself, but devoid of internal "consciousness"/"subjective experience". Even the mere logical possibility of p-zombies indicates that consciousness is unmeasurable.
- trevyn 8y agoConsciousness: Thomas Metzinger’s “The Ego Tunnel” Life and death: Molecular biology
- andrepd 8y agoThe way you curtly replied makes you think that the question is settled, perhaps even trivial, when in reality regarding consciousness that is but one person's thought on an issue where nobody can claim to have an understanding, let alone an answer, and regarding molecular biology there is still much, much to learn.
- make3 8y agohow is death misunderstood?
- perl4ever 8y agoI don't know, but here's some food for thought: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_suicide_and_immortality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_suicide_and_immortalit...
- codethief 8y agoThis is hardly casting doubt on the nature of (human) death. This is purely a question about quantum mechanics, I'd say. On a side note, I fail to see how the experimenter is supposed to survive with probability 1 in Everett's many-worlds interpretation and thus be able to distinguish the latter from the Copenhagen interpretation. Yes, there will be one world where he survives but in the "vast majority" of worlds he will be dead. (Disregarding for a second that counting how often the world bifurcates in the many-worlds interpretation is a somewhat delicate issue.) So in terms of probabilities, he will still die with absolute certainty as the experiment gets repeated infinitely many times.
- perl4ever 8y agoThe idea is that everybody else dies with certainty, from your observation point, but you yourself can't, because the denominator of the probability fraction consists only of those futures where you exist. It happens to be a vivid idea to me, because a long time ago I read a short story that was more fantasy/horror than science fiction, but resembled it a little in spirit. It was about a kid in a small town who discovered that the grave digger for the town seemed to know ahead of time who would die, and dug the graves in advance. The kid thought this was just mildly interesting as long as it was just elderly people he didn't care about, until one day his parents were in a car accident and because one grave was ready, he knew one was going to die. He killed the grave digger and buried him in the open grave instead, and from then on, people stopped dying. Which turned out to not be a blessing.
- perl4ever 8y agoI'm not sure I can conceive of the nature of any of those things being separable from the others, so I wouldn't try to compare them.
- mikec3010 8y agoI dont think time is any more mysterious a concept than space. Asking "what is time" is just as enigmatic as "why are there 3 dimensions and not 1,2,4 or many more?" How can you have a thing that is "left" or "up" of another thing? How come "all the things" aren't in the same place?