9 ms·
Ted Nelson struggles with uncomprehending radio interviewer (1979) [audio]
- DonHopkins 8y agoI love his criticism of IBM (and the literary adjective that perfectly describes IBM that I learned today): Q: Tell me about IBM? A: What would you like to know? OMINOUS LAUGH Q: Well, I'd like to know what's wrong with them, to start with, since that's what you want to talk about. A: Ok. IBM is first and foremost a very slick sales organization, which was created in the image of Thomas J. Watson, a supreme despot, and very imaginative salesman who managed to create an organization with less fat in -- pardon me -- less local fat than any other corporation that ever happened. And one that has over the years learned to devote teams to getting things done. That's the positive side. Get these things done with dispatch and with earnestness. Now whether they're done the way one would like to see them done if one contemplated what the real nature of a problem, this is and entirely different manner. And critics of such things as IBM's 360 and 370 computers would say that they are were Brobdingnagian, clumsy and surrounded by unnecessary difficulties. And this of course is why many people like the kids who showed me around the University of Waterloo this morning far prefer to use systems like Digital Equipment machines which are much more accessible to the sophisticated user. Anyway, the question is why has IBM prevailed in its way, and the answer is that they have a sort of monopoly. And one which obviously has a political side and a technical side. And the problem is now that as they are swinging their new communication system into place, it seems increasingly likely that this communication system is more built to maintain the monopoly than it is built to satisfy the needs of what people ought to have. Q: What communication system? A: Oh there's something called Satellite Business Systems, which IBM and Aetna Life Insurance and I think a few other partners have created in a joint venture.
- thechao 8y agoBrobdignagian is the opposite of Lilliputian—from Gulliver’s travels. It means stupendously gargantuan.
- aportnoy 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brobdingnag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brobdingnag
- JetSpiegel 8y agoBrobdingnag is the "Gulliver's Travels"[1] country where everyone is a giant. Famous for having a breastfeeding woman horrifying the narrator, and him sword fighting a rat. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulliver%27s_Travels#Part_II:_A_Voyage_to_Brobdingnag https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulliver%27s_Travels#Part_II:_...
- DonHopkins 8y agowhoosh -- That's the second literary reference that went over my head when transcribing an interesting Ted Nelson video. I originally guessed he was saying that "Franklin Brouwer Zeus" invented the internet, when he actually said people thought "it sprang from the brow of Zeus". Here is the corrected version: ;) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edZgkNoLdAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=edZgkNoLdAM When we look at the past of computerdom, it's through a lens that's peculiar, because things have changed so much so fast. That to me the 50 years since I've been in the computer field have gone so quickly that the past seems ever-present. In the 60's and 70's, a lot of young people have started communes. And it was a combination of free love, which is a term you don't hear any more because it's taken for granted, and pot, and LSD, and idealism, and hope for a new kind of economy. And that spirit of that age leaked into the computer world. There was a sense of possibility at the beginning that is different because we thought computing would be artisanal. We did not imagine great monopolies. We thought the citizen programmer would be the leader. When I say we I mean I, but of course I had a sense that I was sharing this with a lot of people. We had visions of democratization, of citizen participation, to create vistas of possibility for artistic expression, and artistic expression in software. And software is an art form, though not generally recognized as such. And because of Moore's Law, which has been stated to me not as Moore's Law, but just as a general principle: things will get faster and cheaper. We will be able to afford it. Right now a computer with a screen is $35,000. Tomorrow, who knows. It will be $100 some day. Now is the time to start thinking about what will be the documents of the future. As I would abstract it now, the two concepts were: We can have parallel connections between visible documents. So you can have two pages with a connection saying "this sentence is connected to that paragraph" and see it as a visible strap or bridge. And you can't do that yet. So that was one of my hypertext concepts. And the other hypertext concept was being able to click on something and jump to it. So as the hypertext concept developed and deteriorated over the years, only the jump link became popular in the hypertext systems of the 60's and the 70's, and then Tim Berners Lee created the World Wide Web, which was the sixth or seventh hypertext system on the internet. People think it sprang from the brow of Zeus, in fact it was just a clean job that had the clout of CERN behind it. How to see the possibilities when there are so many things around you that are a certain way? I don't know. The future is an unknown place. There are a lot of scary things about it. What aspects you are going to approach? Are you going to go on thinking about leisure, or about the terrible problems that confront the world? All I can say is: "Close your eyes, and think what might me." My first software designs were largely done with my eyes closed. Thinking: "Now if I hit that key, what should happen? If it hit this key, what should happen?" I was able to imagine -- they say this can't be done, but when my interfaces were built, they always felt the way I knew they would. And the people at Xerox PARC said "That's never possible. You never know how it's going to be." But I did.
- dluan 8y agoThe following short segment is great. "What's swinging into place Max, is that we have great communication networks now coming about for the transmission of digital information. Now by digital we just mean symbols. There's this mistake that digital means in numbers. That's wrong. The two commonest programming languages are musical notation and knitting instructions. That's not fu... why are you laughing." Knitting was really big back then.
- EGreg 8y agoHe forgot recipes :)
- fapjacks 8y agoKnitting is really big still. One of the biggest lobbies for copyright and IP legislation is (no kidding) the industry that creates patterns for sewing and knitting. Put out feelers on social media, see how many of your associates knit which you didn't know about. It was surprising to me for some reason to find out how pervasive it is.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoWait, by sewing pattern industry, do you mean the fashion industry?
- fapjacks 8y agoHaha that's a great question, but no, there is actually a different set of companies selling patterns for sewing and knitting (traditionally to their target demographic of older ladies). Companies that typically sell patterns to places like Hobby Lobby or Michaels, this kind of thing, and not companies like Old Navy and Forever21 and the like. In that industry, patterns are sort of like patents in a way, and these companies have amassed huge libraries of patterns and aggressively defend them with litigation. I'll dig a bit to see if I can find information about the specific events I'm thinking of, but the gist of it was that alongside Napster I believe, one of the biggest and earliest instances of copyright/IP litigation was against little old ladies who were using P2P to fileshare sewing and knitting patterns. This was before the RIAA started suing customers, and I believe it actually partly served as the inspiration for the RIAA stupidly choosing to go that route. It's been some years since I've read the story, so I'm likely not remembering some details correctly. Edit: I can't find a link to the story I'm thinking of, but you can actually find some side effects of this litigation, for example this "copyright notice" (especially read the actual PDF as this notice was pretty clearly issued to protect the interests of these pattern companies I'm talking about): https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/copyright-notice-knitting-and-sewing-patterns https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/copyright-notice-...
- thsowers 8y agoThis is a great listen. The interviewer doesn't seem to understand that there are hard limits to humans ability to search, compute, organize, notice patterns etc
- BenjiWiebe 8y agoHilarious. The poor interviewer just can't comprehend at all what a computer could be used for. Also, Ted Nelson was pretty good at predicting that a computer would be used as a writing medium, a filling cabinet, a musical instrument, a few more things I don't remember specifically. As I was listening I was just silently agreeing that yep, we have that, and that, and that already.
- hobls 8y agoEven hit on what we could now call “smart home” devices. He managed to come up with a lot of examples to try to illustrate to the host what computers would be used for!
- hindsightbias 8y agoI'd wonder if HN readers would have gotten it in the context of 1979. It took nearly three years for someone to wonder what would happen if you connected something like Hypercard to a network. And it wasn't Bill Atkinson.
- BenjiWiebe 8y ago"Remarkable that humanity survived without [a computer] all this time." -sarcastic "Yes it is!" -serious
- dqpb 8y agoI found it striking that the majority of Max Allen's questions/arguments were along the lines of "But isn't everything fine the way it is?"
- sverige 8y agoHe wasn't wrong, either. Having lived the first half of my life without a computer at home and the second half with more and more of them, the only thing I can say is a real improvement is that I can transfer funds from my account to my wife's at any time. The rest isn't that great. Probably hard to understand if you never lived without them.
- mwcampbell 8y agoThat's overly pessimistic. Isn't it awesome that computers have enabled worldwide communities like this one? Asynchronous communication through text, enabled by computers, is also a great equalizer for people with disabilities and other differences. Blind people, deaf people, quadriplegics, people with speech impediments (e.g. stuttering), non-native speakers of the language, etc. can all communicate and work together, without even being aware of each other's difficulties. To be fair, all of that was enabled by the earliest BBSes, and I guess we haven't made as much progress in the meantime as some people (like Engelbart and Nelson) hoped.
- sverige 8y agoYou are correct about asynchronous communication, of course. That is a great thing, and I should have included IRC / texting on the plus side. The worldwide communities? I enjoy them, but it seems to me that it is one of the fundamental causes of the increasing fragmentation of society. Hannah Arendt describe this as 'atomized' society. Totalitarian regimes have flourished in such environments. In the old days, if you didn't fit in, you had to make an effort to find common ground with others physically near you to enjoy a social life. This led to a lot of seredipity and built social cohesion. Nowadays, it's a lot easier to hate your neighbor who disagrees with you politically or culturally because there's always a virtual means of socializing just a click away. Nelson was a visionary to coin 'virtualization' but I think he and many others have been far too optimistic about the end results of that ongoing experiment. It is far easier to manipulate people into committing acts of physical violence against their neighbors than is commonly believed in a society that has become 'atomized,' and virtual communities are a terrific means to creating an atomized society.
- samueloph 8y agoOk, so i didn't know Ted Nelson, from his wikipedia page: "Theodor Holm "Ted" Nelson (born June 17, 1937) is an American pioneer of information technology, philosopher, and sociologist. He coined the terms hypertext and hypermedia in 1963 and published them in 1965." I'm impressed.
- unimpressive 8y agoThe funny thing is that early on in this interview the host tells Nelson that he's the only one saying anything about using computers to store and retrieve text. But that's simply not true, certainly not in 1979. For example, John McCarthy had been describing what largely came to be our digital literary future as early as 1970: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10370990 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10370990 Even within the contemporary environment a significant fraction of computer use was not 'number crunching', but the sorting, retrieval, and printing of essentially textual information. (i.e, records) Records are tiny documents, which to me makes this early portion where Ted accepts the point without argument a large missed opportunity to get the point across. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMYiktO0D64 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMYiktO0D64
- 8bitsrule 8y ago1979 Even 10 years later. In the mid-80s (by which time BYTE magazine was as big as a Sears catalog) I wrote a piece on the approach of the PC era and offered it to a smaller (100K) town's newspaper editor. His response: 'That's kind of a nitch product isn't it?' The bigger newspapers were already moving completely to computers, but such facts hadn't really reached such guys.
- Jedd 8y agoWhile the host - Max Allen - is certainly a bit obtuse and doesn't share the same technical insights & visions of Ted Nelson (hardly surprising given they had significantly different experience and careers) he's respectful of his guest (doesn't interrupt or talk over), concedes various points willingly, appears to genuinely want to understand, and actually enjoys the discussion. The nostalgia sensation isn't just around Ted's prescience.
- EGreg 8y agoThat’s how interviews used to be. FOX News pioneered the interview where the interviewer spends most of the time talking, asking leading questions to the respected person they invited, then cutting them off, shouting them down and attacking them for being socialist or whatever. And on to the next. It’s more like watching gladiator fights than really learning people’s answers to questions.
- andyidsinga 8y agoI really appreciate that too - the interview / discussion is very interesting; draws a lot of good stuff out of Ted Nelson.
- taberiand 8y agoHis viewpoint is also rather reasonable considering the context of the interview, at the dawn of the information age. It's a little depressing however that it's not uncommon to still encounter that point of view today.
- putlake 8y agoBitcoin today is where computers were in 1979. A little embarrassed to admit it but I feel like the short-sighted interviewer who fails to see the applications of the technology.
- inteleng 8y agoJust because something new-ish exists doesn't mean it's the root of something society-changing. Bitcoin might be a steam engine.
- shoo 8y ago> Just because something new-ish exists doesn't mean it's the root of something society-changing. Bitcoin might be a steam engine. this is a great comment, i can interpret it at least two entirely different ways. by "might be a steam engine" do you mean that bitcoin might be one of the key drivers of a major process of economic/industrial revolution?
- inteleng 8y agoI mean it might be completely obsolete in five years. It has caused a great deal of innovation, even if much of that doesn't come to fruition.
- rinze 8y agoBitcoins are tulips.
- nicklaf 8y agoIt would be interesting to ask whether or not Ted Nelson's vision for personal computing has been achieved. In the podcast, personal computing was to be the means of liberation from a centralized priesthood on the one hand, and from ignorance (i.e., access to means of learning) on the other. Personal computers are now ubiquitous, and we've been liberated from central priesthoods which had restricted access to (expensive) computers in the past. But new forms of centralization emerge, whether they arise in the form of bloated, draconian corporate software foisted on workers within a company, or as public products such as Google and Facebook, which have been gobbling up the open web and replacing it with means of control and manipulation. [1] In fact, this latter concern of manipulation begs the question of what people really need computers for, and brings into question Ted Nelson's presumed answer to it: i.e., that people have an inherent need to use computers to facilitate their own creativity. But what about the possibility that the majority of people prefer to be passive consumers? Neil Postman warned that we would become a trivial society, rife with distraction, like in Huxley's Brave New World. [2] Perhaps computers have succeeded in universally capturing our imagination, but corporations (centralization!) have once again captured computing, and by extension our imagination as well, as Tim Wu laments [1]: am I more likely to open up my personal computer at odd moments of the day to check Facebook or Hacker News to momentarily capture my imagination? Or have I instead acquired the habit of pulling out a tablet to accumulate further progress in a creative work, which perhaps only requires internet connectivity for the purpose of reference? And if the answer is the former, is the reason because we don't have actual Dynabooks [3], but instead a more asymmetric device skewed toward consumption and away from creative expression? Or is it because the majority of people in fact prefer passive consumption anyway? [1] http://www.timwu.org/AttentionMerchants.html http://www.timwu.org/AttentionMerchants.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusing_Ourselves_to_Death https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amusing_Ourselves_to_Death [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynabook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynabook
- Jedd 8y agoIt invites or raises the question rather than begs it, but your point is understood. You mention Tim Wu -- his book 'The Master Switch' focuses on the history of technologies as a cycle of invention --> egalitarian use & access --> centralised control and ownership by the elite. My feeling is that things like the trends away from net neutrality globally, and towards greater government surveillance / suppression of encryption, and corporate interest in encouraging consumption via technology rather than (as per your example) 'creative work', are fulfilling that prediction in both obvious and subtle ways.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoWe're still very far from the connected and unified future Ted Nelson had in mind, yet I can't seem to find many people interested in solving that. Where are these people?
- dustingetz 8y agoI'm in that space, link in my profile (not that it is recognizable as a hyperdata system yet, nonetheless it is). Why do you ask – are you?
- jonahx 8y agoThe vicarious frustration in this listen was deep. It's not only a fascinating time-capsule, but a palpable reminder of how revolutionary ideas can be received. The clarity of Ted's thought and vision here is striking even by today's standards, and despite his patience and articulate explanations he might as well be talking to a brick wall. The Swift quote came to mind: > When a true genius appears in the world, you may know him by this sign, that the dunces are all in confederacy against him.
- booleandilemma 8y ago“Don't worry about people stealing your ideas. If your ideas are any good, you'll have to ram them down people's throats” - Howard H. Aiken
- abecedarius 8y agohttp://habitatchronicles.com/2004/04/you-cant-tell-people-anything/ http://habitatchronicles.com/2004/04/you-cant-tell-people-an...
- miguelrochefort 8y agoI spent the last 10 years trying to tell people my vision. Nobody is getting it. Now I understand why. I wish someone told me this 10 years ago. Thank you.
- rocky1138 8y ago> When people ask me about my life’s ambitions, I often joke that my goal is to become independently wealthy so that I can afford to get some work done. Mainly that’s about being able to do things without having to explain them first, so that the finished product can be the explanation. I think this will be a major labor saving improvement. Honestly this is so good. I feel exactly the same.
- DanBC 8y agoIt's a radio interview, so he may be talking to a brick wall in the studio but it's likely a bunch of people listening suddenly "got it" from this interview: computers aren't about manipulating numbers, but are general purpose machines that manipulate symbols.
- shagie 8y agoStarted listening, ok, sounds like an interesting person. Check the Wikipedia page on him... > Theodor Holm "Ted" Nelson (born June 17, 1937) is an American pioneer of information technology, philosopher, and sociologist. He coined the terms hypertext and hypermedia in 1963 and published them in 1965.[1] Nelson coined the terms transclusion,[1] virtuality,[2] and intertwingularity (in Literary Machines), and teledildonics[3]. tele... is that what I think it is? Click link. Yep. The interview is really interesting and how much he got right about the past 30 years.
- oh_sigh 8y agohttps://archive.org/stream/Mondo.2000.Issue.02.1990#page/n53/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/Mondo.2000.Issue.02.1990#page/n53...
- pmoriarty 8y agoThis reminds me of trying to convince a FidoNet BBS sysop in the late 80's to try the Internet. He adamantly refused, saying FidoNet would be all he'd ever need. It also reminds me of arguing in the 80's with an IBM PC user that the Amiga's 4096 colors were desirable. He insisted that 16 colors were all he'd ever need. I also tried to turn my dad on to the Internet and Usenet newsgroups in the late 80's. That failed too. He just wasn't interested. I guess I'm just not a very good salesman.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoThis is how I feel about computers today. They're a mess. The fragmentation of hardware, operating systems, apps, websites, programming languages and frameworks is horrible. I frequently ask people how they feel about the current state of software. Most people think it's fine, they don't have a problem with it. They can't imagine how else it could be. This drives me mad. I have 100 apps on my phone. None of them talk to each other. Every new appliance, restaurant and event has its own app. These 100 apps will quickly turn into 1000. Clearly, the application paradigm doesn't scale. Where is it going to end? We're still emulating the physical world in software. File systems are still trees. Programming is still done with text. Paragraphs are still copy-pasted, rather than dynamically embedded. We barely made any progress since that radio interview. Xanadu is still vaporware. What will it take for a software revolution to take place?
- sverige 8y agoAI is going to invent that revolutionary software, but unfortunately you and I won't understand it or be able to manipulate it. Be careful what you wish for.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoIs it coming soon? I'm not sure I can wait 5 more years.
- sverige 8y agoOh, well, probably not 5 years. More like 20 years away for human-level AI, according to everyone I've read since the 80s. Fusion power will be coming online right around then, too, so that's good. And the true value of the blockchain will finally be evident in about 20 years, too. Which is really good, because that's around the time we are likely to discover the secrets of immortality.
- calebh 8y agoImo gradient descent is not going to get us to general AI. I'm a programming languages theory person, and I also know a fair bit about machine learning. The current problem with neural networks is that they suck at processing variable length data, and they have problems with remembering the past. Programs can be represented by trees, graphs, or text. Deep learning isn't great at dealing with graphs or trees, and it's not that good at text either. The other issue is that deep learning works great for recognizing common patterns, but it sucks when faced with novel situations. So I don't think that we're going to have programs that program anytime soon. The first applications of AI to programming will probably be with programming assistants or with AI guided proof solvers. Programmer productivity will improve, but we're not going to see everyone losing their jobs.
- andyidsinga 8y agothis! Interviewer: "I don't understand what the necessity of an electronic device called a computer, or anything else like that - a computer screen to use your word - is in making people smarter. I don't think another gadget is going to have any effect at all" ... I can't tell you how many times I've heard this gadget/toy statement since I first got a computer when I was around 10. On the flip side - there are so many people with open minds willing to give things a shot (and often a not inexpensive one at that) ...thanks for giving me those computers mom - and then enjoying watching what happened :) (edit : typos)
- redwood 8y agoShadow IT goes back a long way!
- ehnto 8y agoThat title had me thinking he was trying to unthink an epiphany the radio presenter had enlightened him with.
- Rapzid 8y agoReally great interview. Ideas should be challenged, and the value we, the audience, get from the responses to challenge is great. Not enough of this in the mainstream today.
- cm2187 8y agoTo be honest I wouldn't be convinced myself that I would need a personal computer to better index my pieces of text at home. Searching through un-indexed text would have been a far more powerful argument. I remember reading the memoir of a DGSE analyst (the DGSE is the french equivalent of the CIA). As always, the reality of secret services is far less sexy than its popular image and the book has an entire chapter about the importance of good (pre-computer area) archives about everything, every conversation any analyst had with anyone, any book or article written by any public figure, anytime someone is mentioned in any anecdote, etc. And how the essence of being a good analyst is to know these archives inside out, how to quickly browse through when looking for what we know on someone or a topic. On a personal computer that would have been a simple CTR-F.
- Doxin 8y agoTo be fair, that "un-indexed text" is still indexed. The indexing process is just hidden from the user and fully automated.
- braindead_in 8y agoHere's a transcript, if you want to skim through it. https://scribie.com/transcript/290d2d5d863e4353b3843816aade9749d6899bde https://scribie.com/transcript/290d2d5d863e4353b3843816aade9...
- KirinDave 8y agoWow, it's interesting that Ted says the use a computer "during the war" for for trajectory calculations. I wonder if he believes that, or if he's simply avoiding a very complex conversation about information theory and cryptography that in the 70s was both less well-understood and less popular. I wonder if instead he's referring to some other specific event that in the subsequent 50 years we've decided is insignificant to the formation of computers.
- ipsin 8y agoThey used computers during WW II for rangekeeping [1]. They were complicated and heavy electromechanical beasts. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_I_Fire_Control_Computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_I_Fire_Control_Computer
- KirinDave 8y agoRight but this was NOT the most historically significant application of computers in WW2 by a long shot. That's why I'm wondering if this is a visible example of how history tends to redefine significance and refocus on different events over time.
- stan_rogers 8y agoCalculating trajectory tables for artillery was ENIAC's primary job as well.
- hchasestevens 8y agoOne consideration is that much of Bletchley Park's efforts were kept hidden from the public until 1974[1] - it's possible that in 1979 the computer's role in breaking German cyphers was still not widespread knowledge. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra#Postwar_disclosures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra#Postwar_disclosures
- TheTedNelson 8y agoBletchley Park was publicly unknown at the time of the interview. Whereas Eckert and Mauchly, with Eniac, had been computing those tables. (That was a secret too, but it was no longer a secret when I knew him in his last years.)
- xamuel 8y agoInteresting how they mention the coming war between the "computer centers" and the personal computer. And now looking back, we see that's a war that's been fought time and time again, and now we're fighting it all over again with the whole Cloud thing. Next week Cloud'll be out and desktops back in.
- EthanHeilman 8y agoTed Nelson in continuing in a thread of argument first put forth first by Ada Lovelace: "Again, it might act upon other things besides number, were objects found whose mutual fundamental relations could be expressed by those of the abstract science of operations, and which should be also susceptible of adaptations to the action of the operating notation and mechanism of the engine. Supposing, for instance, that the fundamental relations of pitched sounds in the science of harmony and of musical composition were susceptible of such expression and adaptations, the engine might compose elaborate and scientific pieces of music of any degree of complexity or extent." Sketch of The Analytical Engine Invented by Charles Babbage By L. F. MENABREA of Turin, Officer of the Military Engineers With notes upon the Memoir by the Translator ADA AUGUSTA, COUNTESS OF LOVELACE https://www.fourmilab.ch/babbage/sketch.html https://www.fourmilab.ch/babbage/sketch.html
- andyidsinga 8y agoI'm listening to this for the second time - I think there will be more.
- Kaius 8y ago"It is possible to insist that every changes is merely a small change in degree, rather than a change in kind." Good quote from Ted.