3 ms·
It is not wikileaks job to prevent people from getting harmed, nor is it their job to help America fight is wars. The sole, only and absolute job of wikileaks
by tomjen3 16y ago
It is not wikileaks job to prevent people from getting harmed, nor is it their job to help America fight is wars.
The sole, only and absolute job of wikileaks is to leak information, which they have done very well.
If the US leadership can't fight their wars because of it, that is their problem, not wikileaks.
- tptacek 16y agoThis is a tautology. The same logic animates the sentence "It is not the job of the Kill-bot 3000 to prevent people from getting harmed; it is the job of the Kill-bot 3000 to kill puppies, a job it has done very well". Maybe it is right and sensible that Wikileaks provides the information that it does. But it is clearly not automatically immune from ethical/moral responsibility for its actions.
- krschultz 16y agoI wouldn't make that argument, because the conclusion is one that ends very poorly for Wikileaks. I like the concept of Wikileaks, they were leaking valuable information, and seemingly handling it in a way that minimized the risk of harm to people on all sides. If their actual mentality was aligned with your post, meaning their goal was to leak information and ignore the consequences, then I would fully support the US doing everything in their power to stop them.