3 ms·
What you describe is your boss's boss exercising power within his job position. That is not the case Kuhn describes. When someone comes to you to have handle s
by eesmith 8y ago
What you describe is your boss's boss exercising power within his job position. That is not the case Kuhn describes.
When someone comes to you to have handle something which should be handled by your boss's boss, do you go ahead and do it? Even if you don't want to, and it's outside of your job description?
I have read about Kuhn and Sandler. I have also listened to most of their oggcasts.
You write "The reputation alone is the reason why the donor wants to speak with him"
Do you have evidence that that is the case? Because as presented, we don't know the specific reasons, and Kuhn states that "I can't think of a single reason this donor could want to speak to me that would not be more productive if he instead spoke with Karen". I presume Kuhn doesn't think his reputation is relevant.
Nor do I see a reason to think that Bradley's reputation is relevant. If the donor wants to speak to Bradley, why gate the donation on the private meeting? Why not donate the money without that thread attached, and independently arrange a private meeting with Kuhn?
Also, Sandler also has a reputation. She has been in the free software community for 13 years, has a legal background in defending free software, is the Executive Director, and (according to Kuhn), "better than [him] at the key jobs of a successful Executive Director."
The question isn't "why would someone want to have a private conversation with Kuhn?" but "why would a donor gate a donation on having a private conversation with Kuhn?"
It is certainly not "immediately obvious" that Sandler shouldn't also be at that conversation. Can you explain why it's obvious to you?
The "disingenuous" comment I made you mentioned is because the OP wrote "unfathomable", which is an extremist viewpoint which sidesteps the topic. I can make up fathomable reasons - and indeed I did - but they are all much more improbable than the stated reason of institutional sexism.
- charmides 8y ago>You write "The reputation alone is the reason why the donor wants to speak with him" >Do you have evidence that that is the case? OP does not have the burden to prove something about the donor's motives. The burden is on the author who wrote this inflammatory article, because he is the person who is making a claim that the donor is sexist.
- eesmith 8y agoWhat level of evidence is enough? Why can we not accept what the author writes? What motive does he have to tell something other than his best interpretation of the evidence? I have read and listened to far more from Kuhn than I have of you or the other commenters here on HN. That has lead me to conclude that this is not something he makes lightly or for ulterior motives.
- charmides 8y ago>What level of evidence is enough? Much more than what the author presented. >Why can we not accept what the author writes? Because when people make ugly accusations against others, they need to show evidence. >I have read and listened to far more from Kuhn than I have of you or the other commenters here on HN. Your perceived intimacy with the people in question does not work in your favor. On the contrary, it is more likely to make you biased.
- eesmith 8y ago"intimacy"? What a delightful word. I am intimate with my partner. I have intimate friends. This is the first time I've ever been told I'm intimate with someone who I've never met, who I only know about through public writings and talks, and to whom I've never communicated. My circle of intimacy instantly expanded as it now includes Richard Feynman, Freeman Dyson, Eugene Garfield, and Donald Knuth. Though to be fair, I have communicated with the latter two. And all those people who write critical biographies of dead people - surely we can't trust them now as they are too intimate to the person in question, and thus more likely to be biased. Indeed, the only people we can trust are those who know nothing at all.
- charmides 8y agoFirst, I am an ESL speaker. If you have nothing left to contribute except to nitpick my choice of words ('unfathomable' and 'pereived intimacy'), then you have obviously lost this debate. Second, I don't believe that you have never met those people. Based on your activity here and emotional investment, I find it more likely that you are affiliated with the charity or maybe even the author himself. Notice that there isn't a single other person in this comment section who is defending the author, but you are responding to everything.