11 ms·
I got zero sense of a 'highly submissive (almost grovelling) attitude'. I got a strong sense of irritation and annoyance that people still, after many years, h
by eesmith 8y ago
I got zero sense of a 'highly submissive (almost grovelling) attitude'.
I got a strong sense of irritation and annoyance that people still, after many years, have not understood the organizational structure. He's using repetition to make it clear, in no uncertain terms, that his boss really is his boss.
Kuhn writes "I can't think of a single reason this donor could want to speak to me that would not be more productive if he instead spoke with Karen."
Since you don't know what he's done, why do you second-guess his explicit statement by positing "is it unfathomable that he has accomplished something that some donor would like to speak to him about privately."
Apparently yes, it is unfathomable to Kuhn and Sandler.
True, it's possible that the donor is (say) hoping for a private meeting with Kuhn to proposition him for a one-night stand - we can imagine many such scenarios which are broader than the simple context of a donor relationship to a non-profit. But these then become much more improbable than the stated view that the donor used a gender biased viewpoint to misjudge the dynamics involved.
You write "they are being very assuming about the donor's motives and beliefs" - but compare that with Kuhn's phrase "repeatedly insisted that the donation was gated on a conversation with me". If there were a reasonable explanation, perhaps based on Kuhn's past accomplishments, why didn't the donor say so explicitly?
Or are you proposing that the donor did say so, and that Kuhn is hiding the response, in order to misdirect us? You know little of him, so what is the basis of your doubt?
I cannot easily reconcile what you wrote, when I compare it to the original text, as something other than trivializing institutionalized sexism.
- jbob2000 8y ago> I got a strong sense of irritation and annoyance that people still, after many years, have not understood the organizational structure. He's using repetition to make it clear, in no uncertain terms, that his boss really is his boss People aren’t as rigid as the organizational structure wants them to be. My boss is also my boss, but when his boss wants to cut through the bs and get stuff done, he comes right to me. Humans are fluid like that. You can read about Bradley, he’s been around the open source community for decades. The reputation alone is the reason why the donor wants to speak with him, how is that not immediately obvious? Why be disingenuous and think that it is something more insidious (why would you even suggest something sexual? There was no indication of that....)?
- eesmith 8y agoWhat you describe is your boss's boss exercising power within his job position. That is not the case Kuhn describes. When someone comes to you to have handle something which should be handled by your boss's boss, do you go ahead and do it? Even if you don't want to, and it's outside of your job description? I have read about Kuhn and Sandler. I have also listened to most of their oggcasts. You write "The reputation alone is the reason why the donor wants to speak with him" Do you have evidence that that is the case? Because as presented, we don't know the specific reasons, and Kuhn states that "I can't think of a single reason this donor could want to speak to me that would not be more productive if he instead spoke with Karen". I presume Kuhn doesn't think his reputation is relevant. Nor do I see a reason to think that Bradley's reputation is relevant. If the donor wants to speak to Bradley, why gate the donation on the private meeting? Why not donate the money without that thread attached, and independently arrange a private meeting with Kuhn? Also, Sandler also has a reputation. She has been in the free software community for 13 years, has a legal background in defending free software, is the Executive Director, and (according to Kuhn), "better than [him] at the key jobs of a successful Executive Director." The question isn't "why would someone want to have a private conversation with Kuhn?" but "why would a donor gate a donation on having a private conversation with Kuhn?" It is certainly not "immediately obvious" that Sandler shouldn't also be at that conversation. Can you explain why it's obvious to you? The "disingenuous" comment I made you mentioned is because the OP wrote "unfathomable", which is an extremist viewpoint which sidesteps the topic. I can make up fathomable reasons - and indeed I did - but they are all much more improbable than the stated reason of institutional sexism.
- charmides 8y ago>You write "The reputation alone is the reason why the donor wants to speak with him" >Do you have evidence that that is the case? OP does not have the burden to prove something about the donor's motives. The burden is on the author who wrote this inflammatory article, because he is the person who is making a claim that the donor is sexist.
- eesmith 8y ago
- charmides 8y ago>Since you don't know what he's done, why do you second-guess his explicit statement by positing "is it unfathomable that he has accomplished something that some donor would like to speak to him about privately." >Apparently yes, it is unfathomable to Kuhn and Sandler. I am second-guessing it because it obviously not unfathomable that the author, who has many years of experience in his field, has accomplished something that someone finds worthy of a private conversation. When there is any doubt of people's motives, you should not go around and assume the worst, let alone make angry, public accusations. >I cannot easily reconcile what you wrote, when I compare it to the original text, as something other than trivializing institutionalized sexism. It is regrettable that you had to add an inappropriate accusation like this to your comment. I hope you are more respectful in your daily life when you encounter people with opposite viewpoints to your own.
- eesmith 8y agoPlease explain your use of the term "unfathomable." I interpret it to mean that there is no possible, conceivable reason other than the one given. I believe this term is inappropriate, as it implies that "unfathomable" is somehow an appropriate guideline. The guideline should be "reasonable". Otherwise, I pointed out a 'fathomable' but unreasonable scenario. I can easily create more 'fathomable' but unreasonable scenarios. I believe the use of an extremist term like "unfathomable" serves to trivialize the topic made by making the goal posts too high. What is a reasonable scenario where a potential donor to the Conservancy, when told several times they should be dealing with Sandler, still insists on a private meeting with Kuhn (and not Sandler) as condition of the donation? I can fully understand why someone might want a private conversation with Kuhn, because of his background and experience. The question at hand, however, is why a private conversation with Kuhn is a gating condition for the donation. I strongly doubt that the only way to have a private conversation with Kuhn is by contributing to the Conservancy. So, what scenario do you propose which is more reasonable than institutional sexism?