5 ms·
The headline gives it away "At Last, Women on Top". Wasn't this supposed to be about equality?
by gaius 16y ago
The headline gives it away "At Last, Women on Top". Wasn't this supposed to be about equality?
- houseabsolute 16y agoTemporary overcorrection seems more equitable than a longer time before reaching true equality. I.e. this[1] is OK. Or, even better, in this image[2] we prefer the light blue line to the green line, because it is more equitable overall. [1] http://www.newport.com/images/web600w-EN/images/1231942.gif http://www.newport.com/images/web600w-EN/images/1231942.gif [2] http://i.cmpnet.com/embedded/gifs/2000/0010/0010feat3fig17.gif http://i.cmpnet.com/embedded/gifs/2000/0010/0010feat3fig17.g...
- awakeasleep 16y agoI don't like that either, but when I think about how complicated control systems are, it eases my mind a bit. A system that oscillates towards the goal seems to be reasonable and even expected when you're dealing with something as complex as success in life. Of course, it SUCKS that anyone is ever on the wrong end of that oscillation.
- gaius 16y agoHalf the population will be paid above average, half below, obviously. But feminists think the top half is men-only, and they want it to be women-only.
- gxti 16y ago> But feminists think the top half is men-only, and they want it to be women-only. Stating this as if it were fact is disingenuous. The feminists that people think of when they think that -- the ones they label "feminazis" -- exist only in their heads as a stereotype. People actually resembling that stereotype of extremity are few and far between and can be safely ignored. The vast majority of progressively-minded people, even those who call themselves feminists, lobby only for equality/parity, not supremacy.
- crystalis 16y agoSome extreme stereotypes end up with a disproportionate amount of mindshare - Christine O'Donnell and Sarah Palin seem like reasonable examples of this. [You could also consider those in charge of the Texas Board of Education rewriting history and science in textbooks that will be used across the whole country, or the particular people who create the often decidedly institutionally sexist terms of e.g., rape victim anonymity or child support.]
- gaius 16y agoI'll believe that when I see feminists clamouring for the dirty, dangerous, low-paid jobs too, in the name of "equality". They all look up and see CEOs, they never look down and see miners, meatpackers, refuse collectors... 98% of those killed at work are men.
- crystalis 16y ago(This and other related bits in http://www.psy.fsu.edu/~baumeistertice/goodaboutmen.htm http://www.psy.fsu.edu/~baumeistertice/goodaboutmen.htm , with discussions http://searchyc.com/submissions/is+there+anything+good http://searchyc.com/submissions/is+there+anything+good)
- gxti 16y agoThe unfortunate truth about humans is that nobody looks down unless it serves to further raise their own status, even if only in a subconscious, primal sort of way (consider how working with the poor is likely to increase respect towards you, and how you may unknowingly seek this praise). It's hardly something unique to feminists. But that wasn't really pertinent to my point in any case -- I was just trying to save you from categorically stating that an entire movement consisting of many millions of people was somehow arguing for a total bias reversal. Or at least they're not lobbying for it visibly. Maybe they really believe that, but you'd have a hard time getting them to admit to it. That said, I haven't seen any evidence that this is the case.
- 1va 16y agoYou make this general point (correct me if I'm wrong, but I think your argument is that feminists care more about equality at the top end of the scale than the bottom) a couple of times in this thread. I'm not quite sure what you are trying to say. If you mean that feminists don't pursue discrimination cases when it comes to low-pay/low-prestige/high-risk jobs, that's demonstrably false: There are many examples of "women's lib" folks organizing factories or migrant workers or whatever. Many of the related Supreme Court cases (e.g. Ledbetter, Chrapliwy) were about discrimination in blue collar jobs at factories. It is likely that these groups spend more time and money pursuing discrimination issues in blue-collar and low-wage workplaces than they do in the higher-salary, higher-prestige jobs, not least of which because (a) discrimination is probably more blatant and common there and (b) more people, men and women both, have below average (arithmetic mean) incomes than have above average salaries and (c) more women have low-pay, low-prestige jobs than men. If you mean that feminists hold up the gender imbalance in high-wage, high-prestige jobs when advocating for their cause, of course they do. Everyone would. What middle class donor is going to pull out their wallet to ensure their daughters can get janitorial jobs? The aspirational jobs are simply more inspiring. Moreover, ensuring a gender balance in the lowest-wage, lowest-prestige job categories while leaving the top end alone isn't really achieving equality, is it? By the way, I don't think your notion that women are under-represented in low pay/low prestige jobs holds up to scrutiny anyway. Women are over-represented in the lowest end of the scale, and under-represented in the highest end of the scale. Take a look at BLS or Census Bureau data on the highest and lowest paying jobs and the distribution of women and men in each. Here's an interesting table of unemployment rate by occupation and sex: http://www.infoplease.com/business/employment-rate-occupation-2008-2009.html http://www.infoplease.com/business/employment-rate-occupatio.... Note that the unemployment rate pretty closely correlates to what you'd expect from a gender bias: the unemployment rate in traditionally feminine occupations is higher for men than for women, the unemployment rate in traditionally masculine occupations is higher for women than for men. I think the only claim in your line of thinking that holds up to the least bit of scrutiny is that men are over-represented in dangerous job categories, or more to the point that men account for a disproportionate share of workplace fatalities. This is true (although your numbers are a bit off). The breakdown of hours worked by sex is around 55% men to 45% women. The breakdown of fatal injuries is around 93% men and 7% women. But with only 4,300 workplace fatalities in the United States in 2009, we're talking about one fatality for every 59 million hours worked. Workplace fatalities are not the biggest labor problem in the US, probably not even for the most dangerous occupations. I don't mean to flog this thread that is fairly dead at this point, but seriously, the level of largely unchallenged inaccuracy, "truthiness", and borderline misogyny in this thread is not only well below HN's typical level of quality, but frankly it is disturbing. This conversation needs some balance. The parent comment here currently has 15 upvotes. Another comment on this page claiming there hasn't been gender based discrimination "for a very long time" has 3 upvotes. Many of the claims made in these posts are simply demonstrably false. They seem to represent some kind of knee-jerk, well, not misogyny, but something approaching it. Is there a term for "dislike of women" in place of "hatred of women"? I'm male, but gender inequality and discrimination in the workplace is obvious to me, let alone to the women in my life. Gender isn't the dominant factor in predicting income, rank or career success. It may not even be among the top few factors. But it is certainly a factor, and not a negligible one at that. To be candid I'm both astounded and troubled this isn't obvious to more of the participants in this conversation.
- crystalis 16y agoMedians do exist- everyone "could" fit in an average salary.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Half the population will be paid above average, half below, obviously. It depends on the distribution. I would assume it's not exactly symmetrical.
- pigbucket 16y agoThe title gives nothing away except for the fact that some editor, not possessing the usual unimpeachable standards of his calling, decided to sacrifice meaning for sensation. The first sentence of the article points out that the avg. woman earns 8/10 of the avg. man's wage. Equality is still a ways off. Also, the women in the studied group are being paid more because they are on avg. more highly educated; there is no suggestion that they are getting paid more for the same work.
- tomjen3 16y agoYes, but that was a long time ago - women haven't really been discriminated against in any serious, society wide way for a very long time.
- houseabsolute 16y agoI can think of a few ways they continue to be discriminated against: - More likely to be the victim of a rape. - Representation in the media. http://bechdeltest.com/ http://bechdeltest.com/ I'm sure there are more that a better feminist than myself could share with you.
- gaius 16y agoAnd men are more likely to get knifed. It's not about competing to see who can be the biggest victim and win the most stuff out of sympathy.
- houseabsolute 16y agoI agree that it's not about competing to see who can be the biggest victim. I doubt most women wish to be victimized in any way at all. Nonetheless, considering women have been oppressed by men historically and still are in many countries in the world, it seems like a lot of confidence would be required to assert that we have fully eradicated such systemic oppression here. It would require a level of confidence I do not have.
- Gormo 16y agoHow do either of those statistics indicate the existence of discrimination?
- sophacles 16y agoActually there is one big one I can think of: women's fashions vs mens fashions. The fashions and hairdos and whatnot for women just plain require a lot of work to look right. Combined with makeup, it is a big deal. To look decent, most women need to spend 30-60 minutes a day on that stuff. This really adds up, imagine an hour of your day on nothing but preening. You could argue that "they don't need to" and I call bullshit. Go down to the nearest college and pay attention to the comments made about the female grad students who do eschew the preening hour vs the comments about those who don't. It is absurd. A man who doesn't bother to do his hair right is "eccentric" or "a bit of a slob" but this trangression is quickly overlooked (a fact many geeks take great advantage of). A woman doing the same will forever be looked down on as 'that frumpy chick' or 'she could really be something if she took care of herself'. Do you see the difference in how the value judgement plays out?