3 ms·
> lobbyists who wanted to sell as many cars as they could. That's such a boring scapegoat. Rail was a plenty powerful industry at the time who afforded themsel
by Spivak 8y ago
> lobbyists who wanted to sell as many cars as they could.
That's such a boring scapegoat. Rail was a plenty powerful industry at the time who afforded themselves plenty of lobbyists. Personal vehicles were a literal revolution. What always seems left out is that people overwhelmingly wanted this state of affairs and largely still do. People here are acting like people would love public transportation if only their minds hadn't been corrupted by the bad people.
> It's overwhelmingly shit because urban planning favoured cookie-cutter suburbs.
But now that we're here what do you propose we do? Going back in time for a do over isn't exactly a solution.
> People won't pay out of pocket to upgrade infrastructure.
* People who own cars don't use public transportation and have little desire to start.
* The overwhelming majority of people own cars.
* Public transportation comprehensive enough to replace cars is ludicrously expensive.
* People who don't use a thing don't want to pay for a thing.
=> It's not exactly a leap in logic that people wouldn't vote for it.
I think you've got a better chance of creating programs that just outright buy cars for the poor.
- ljm 8y agoFair points, but it feels like the product of an intensely individualistic society and at some point the impact of that has to be taken into consideration, considering the effect it has on government, policy, and culture. If a group can look at evidence of successful public transport (and other things) and still decide that can never work for them, for various nonsensical reasons (big country, x million people, the guiding hand of the free market, whatever), then they can at least be honest with themselves and say what their problem really is.