3 ms·
I don't think the article makes any sort of objective point. The author essentially says "I don't like it, it's cheesy." Well, I can just as easily say "I lik
by dangus 8y ago
I don't think the article makes any sort of objective point.
The author essentially says "I don't like it, it's cheesy."
Well, I can just as easily say "I like some of these facadist buildings." And I do.
If the author spoke with some more concrete reasoning about why these buildings are such abominations, perhaps I could be convinced. Until then, it's hard not to consider this just another example of every design feature having good and bad executions.
There are timeless Brutalist, Modernist, Classical, and Contemporary buildings just like there are ugly, unremarkable, bad examples. The same is probably true of Facadism.
I think the only argument that comes close (which the author didn't get into enough) might be the destruction of historic buildings as an alternative to full restoration. I wish more effort was taken to quantify this concept. In other words, present a particular example of a building project and demonstrate to the reader with real data why it would have worked better as a restoration project, complete tear-down, or otherwise handle the project differently.
There must often be a functional desire to build a modern building, perhaps one that provides more comfort, natural light, safety, accessibility, flexibility, square footage, etc.
Finally, it should be mentioned that buildings are owned by private companies and individuals, who generally have a right to do whatever they want to them!
- wahern 8y ago> Finally, it should be mentioned that buildings are owned by private companies and individuals, and generally have a right to do whatever they want to them! For better or worse, that's just not true. Since at least the 1800s American cities have used building codes to limit and control construction. Historic zoning rules are far more recent but the courts have been unwilling to draw lines to delineate legitimate from illegitimate public interest policies. The only real limits have been due process-related, so effected owners are at least nominally given notice and can't be singled out. However, courts have been unwilling to even enforce those protections, which is why in major American cities quid pro quo systems (exactions for permits so the city doesn't slow walk your project) have metastasized. And SCOTUS has been hesitant to jump into the fray because even they fear the wrath of NIMBYs flooding the courts with decades of challenges if courts take up the mantle of arbiter from local commissions.
- so33 8y ago>There are timeless Brutalist, Modernist, Classical, and Contemporary buildings just like there are ugly, unremarkable, bad examples. The same is probably true of Facadism. I think one of the original goals of facadism was to blend a new, contemporary building into its surroundings (which would be older historic buildings). As more facadism gets built, I think they stop blending in as much. Combine this with the likely phenomenon of developers pursuing a hot new trend and now suddenly all of these buildings stick out like a sore thumb.
- cleansy 8y ago> Finally, it should be mentioned that buildings are owned by private companies and individuals, who generally have a right to do whatever they want to them! Err, no. A city can and should decide what the "overall look and feel" is. London fails at that spectacularly. Pretty much all cities that are considered beautiful have building guidelines in place that support that. Like: you can build only to the height of neighboring buildings, windows need to line up, specific styles and mandatory balconies to fit into the environment. Think of Amsterdam or Barcelona. The overall look of a city is part of the quality of life of its citizens. If you leave it to property developers, well, you get something like London. EDIT: "The school of Life" made a video that explains that pretty well. [1] 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hy4QjmKzF1c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hy4QjmKzF1c
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> A city can and should decide what the "overall look and feel" is. London fails at that spectacularly. London's skyline is one of the most iconic skylines in the world. The more recent additions like the London Eye (or whatever it's called these days), the "walkie talkie" and the Shard just add to its unique character IMO.
- cleansy 8y agoAn iconic skyline sure. But unless you are one of the few who can afford renting/buying and apartment higher up you mostly notice how much shadow a cluster of high rise buildings casts onto the street level. Walking from the tube to my office I noticed 3 story buildings next to 10, then 5 then 3 again. Old brick buildings next to soviet style apartment blocks. Even for the pavement they used 6 different materials or styles from the station to the office, around 400m. It is not that hard nor expensive to make an attractive looking city. You just need the political will for it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoIndeed. I agree with the author that the examples shown are monstrous eyesores. But take a walk around London and you'll be able to find plenty of examples of this "facadism" done well.