3 ms·
No! Selective enforcement is terrible, if there's a revenue threshold bake it into the law, otherwise you'll see large companies crying foul on some up-and-com
by munk-a 8y ago
No! Selective enforcement is terrible, if there's a revenue threshold bake it into the law, otherwise you'll see large companies crying foul on some up-and-coming competitor that then gets bogged down in legislation, along with all the other terrible thing inherit in selectively enforced laws.
- bmelton 8y ago> if there's a revenue threshold bake it into the law There's no real winning there either. If you bake the threshold into the law, some companies may game the system such that, if the cost of total compliance is x, and we're revenue range of x, give or take, to just take a little less money to stay under the threshold. Not that I'm suggesting that is something that we should care about, or even consider a majority worry, but hard and fast cliffs lead to gamesmanship, or worse, misaligned incentives (such that it's non-beneficial for those on welfare to work if it puts them over a given benefits threshold.) On the whole, I agree that selective enforcement is bad, if not wholly terrible, but its absence isn't a panacea either.
- ggcdn 8y agoI think there is a threshold of $100,000 or 200 separate transactions in the South Dakota law that was being challenged [1]. [1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/17-494_j4el.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/17-494_j4el.pdf
- fludlight 8y agoThe 200 transactions is basically the lower bound here unless your ASP is >$500. Sell something for 99 cents to 200 people? Congrats, now you have to spend more than your revenue worth of time.
- ubernostrum 8y agoI spent the last couple years working at a company in a highly-regulated space. I agree with the comment you replied to, and "selective enforcement" is not how I'd describe it. Think of, say, a teacher. Suppose a teacher gives a complex assignment, provides contact information and says students can and should ask questions, submit drafts for feedback, etc. And there are two students who take different approaches. Student A simply glances over the assignment sheet, goes off and does what they want, then hands it in on the last day. Student B asks questions early and often to clarify anything they're not sure about, runs a draft or two past the teacher, and makes changes in response to feedback. Student B is much more likely to get a good grade on the assignment. Student A is much more likely to get a low grade out of the blue for making serious mistakes. And this isn't selective grading, it's just a reflection of the effort each student put into getting the assignment right. Both students had equal opportunity to put in that effort, but only Student B actually did, and it shouldn't be seen as a problem if Student B's diligence pays off.
- fludlight 8y agoRerun that scenario with a large (5000+), but unknown, number of teachers each giving one or more assignments which may or may not be assigned to a particular student. That's sales tax in the USA.