3 ms·
The claim was that Koko could use ASL (American Sign Language). This is not even supported by the main researcher's, Francine Patterson's, own work: Even at th
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
The claim was that Koko could use ASL (American Sign Language). This is not even supported by the main researcher's, Francine Patterson's, own work:
Even at the level of hand shapes, the degree of correspondence is questionable.
An unspecified number of Koko’s hand shapes were reduced or modified from the
citation forms in ASL because of the ape’s lack of manual dexterity and other
limitations. From Patterson’s discussion (pp. 80-86), it appears that she
modified Koko’s signs extensively, and that the resulting formational criteria
for any given sign were quite loose. She states, “For example, water and rubber
are simplified from the W and X hand configurations [in ASL], respectively, to
a forefinger extended from a loose or compact fist” (p. 80). It is clear that
Patterson tolerated variations in the form of an individual sign which in ASL
would change its meaning entirely. Note that signs modified in this manner are
not ASL signs. More importantly, her examples lead one to question how she
could unequivocably determine the “meaning” of a particular hand shape. How,
for example, did she determine whether Koko was signing water or rubber?
Similarly, many of Koko’s signs were apparently formed by merely pointing
(e.g., this, that, there, you, etc.). How were these signs differentiated?
Patterson glossed one hand movement as the sign “comegimme.” Come, give, and me
are three semantically distinct words; in ASL they are physically distinct
signs. It appears in this case that Koko used a beckoning gesture which was
compatible with both “come” and “gimme” interpretations. Patterson’s hedging on
the interpretation of this behavior is inconsistent with her assignment of very
specific meanings to other signs (e.g., pound, in the sense of striking
something), and her fine distinctions between highly semantically related signs
(e.g., candy and sweet).
From:
On the evidence for linguistic abilities in signing apes; Laura A.Petitto, Mark S.Seidenberg.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0093934X79900476 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0093934X79...
The claims that Koko learned sign language seem to have been the result of very subjective interpretations of her behaviour.