5 ms·
There is a better explanation. Being talented individual is not enough. They have to play against other equally talented individuals in the highest level prof
by nabla9 8y ago
There is a better explanation.
Being talented individual is not enough. They have to play against other equally talented individuals in the highest level professional leagues from the age of 18 to develop tactically and technically. China needs a professional soccer league with top level foreigners or they need to send their best to European leagues. They can do it but it can take several generations.
Soccer is the most popular sport in the world and has most professional athletes by far. Best individuals from all over the world go to play in best professional teams, mostly in Europe and they continue to grow with better opponents and teammates. Talented Brazilians playing in top leagues all over the world a bring all that with them to their national team. Iceland (population little over 300,000) has professional players playing in England, Russia, Sweden, Netherlands ...
- WhompingWindows 8y agoIceland's success is probably not reproducible in a larger nation. Due to their numerous indoor fields, which draw on the plentiful/cheap electricity from geothermal power to keep the lights heated and grass growing, and their plethora of coaches (I heard 500 per capita) for their 300k population, it's really not feasible in China.
- GFischer 8y agoHere in Uruguay we don´t have cheap energy but we do have a ridiculous number of both professional and amateur leagues and coaches (and a lot of grassland to convert into soccer fields) For a population of 3 million: - Pro league with 30 pro teams (each with a youth system with 7-8 teams) + 80 semi-amateur teams (with promotion to the pro leagues) That's between 10.000 and 20.000 players in the pro system. 100 (or more) each year are sold overseas. - Very serious amateur league with 8.000 players every weekend in the capital city, Montevideo (any of those 8.000 players could be a pro in a weak national league) plus 2.000 players in the league for smaller cities. - Teenagers play leagues much like Americans might play high school and college sports, there are probably 30.000 teenagers playing in leagues - 140.000 players in all the leagues across all the smaller cities. So that's about 200.000 active players for a population of 3 million - I was one until a few years ago :) If China or India could achieve that much sports penetration (imagine 200.000.000 Chinese playing competitive soccer every weekend!), I don't doubt they'd be one of the top ranked teams in the world. https://www.ovaciondigital.com.uy/futbol/mundo-futbolistas.html https://www.ovaciondigital.com.uy/futbol/mundo-futbolistas.h... https://www.referi.uy/tierra-fertil-2017-emigraron-107-jugadores-casi-10-equipos-n1155154 https://www.referi.uy/tierra-fertil-2017-emigraron-107-jugad...
- tiuPapa 8y agoIndia has the penetration with cricket. Football has been growing, but I don't see any significant improvement happening before at least a decade.
- bohadi 8y ago500 coaches per capita? Energy resources for success in soccer? I'm happy for their team to go far this tournament as much as the next guy, but what in the world are you talking about?!
- vraid 8y ago> I heard 500 per capita You may have swapped your units there. 150 million coaches would be somewhat excessive for a population of 300 thousand.
- sotojuan 8y ago> from the age of 18 18 is too late. I doubt any one in any of the good national teams started playing seriously and tactically at age 18. This is in fact one of the problems with the US - our soccer players start too late.
- narag 8y agoThey have to play against other equally talented individuals in the highest level professional leagues from the age of 18 to develop tactically and technically. Exactly. Nothing teaches better than having your ass kicked. A number of high profile spanish players are considering going China for their last active years, so maybe they're on the right way.
- KSS42 8y agoAnother counter point is the USSR excelling in hockey. They even had star players : i.e. Vladislav Tretiak.
- masonic 8y agoTretiak is so highly regarded in the hockey world, numerous NHL goalies have worn #20 to honor him (including non-Russians like Ed Belfour).