3 ms·
> Grover Norquist, president of the anti-tax group Americans for Tax Reform, said in a statement, "Today the Supreme Court said yes -- you can be taxed by poli
by jedberg 8y ago
> Grover Norquist, president of the anti-tax group Americans for Tax Reform, said in a statement, "Today the Supreme Court said yes -- you can be taxed by politicians you do not elect and who act knowing you are powerless to object."
That doesn't follow. The people being taxed are the people living in that state, and their representatives are enacting that tax. As usually Norquist is making up BS to scare people.
- anonymous5133 8y agoIt is so significant of a claim that brings the question...does norquist know how sales/use tax even works?
- jedberg 8y agoI'm sure he does. He just likes to abuse his position as a "tax expert" to say outrageous things and people believe him. He's very good at it.
- anonymous5133 8y agoHe likes to throw gasoline on a fire, ill give him that.
- spaginal 8y agoIf a state the business doesn’t operate in imposes the requirement to collect sales tax on your business out of state, you do have a multitude of costs and issues as a small business. If the federal government wished to circumvent this with a VAT split amongst the states, that is one thing, both sane and constitutional in the face of this, but this invites a mess. First, if you are required to possess a sales tax license with that state, and potentially municipalities or jurisdictions within the state that require the fees and paperwork yearly, there is one huge cost, both in time and fees. No software will absolve your liability of this if you mess it up or dont pay the fees, you as the business own it. If you are required to file monthly or quarterly statements with the state along with any remittances, there is time and costs there. File late, file incorrectly, fees and interest on top of the tax obligation. Refuse or forget to pay the tax to a jurisdiction in backwater Alaska, time and money to wrestle with tax auditors from another state if they pursue action. How will the states negotiate auditors and tax authorities stepping all over eachother within their jurisdictions. Need to purchase extra services to juggle the spiderweb of compliance, reporting, and remittance issues, there is also more cost, whether in your additional time ($), accountants ($), or third party services ($). Keep in mind, none of these things absolve you of liability if you mess this up. He is absolutely right.
- jedberg 8y agoYou aren't being forced though. You can just choose not to sell to anyone in that state if you don't like the terms. The only place you can't do that is the place where your business actually is, and in theory you get to vote there. So he's totally wrong -- you're not being forced to do anything. You're choosing to pay the tax.
- ScottBurson 8y agoI too would prefer to see a federal VAT, but that would not receive Norquist's blessing any more than this has. Anyway, this decision leaves the door very much open for Congress to step in and fix things; it just throws out the nexus rule created by the Court in the Quill decision. One would think that Republicans would celebrate the reversal of an example of "legislating from the bench".
- datamingle 8y agoThink of it from the perspective of the business selling goods. Then the quote makes more sense.
- jethro_tell 8y agoThe business isn't paying the tax though? If the people paying the tax don't want it, they should replace their reps or move to a state that doesn't have that tax. So we could think of it from the point of the business but that wouldn't be based in fact.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Cerium 8y agoIf the business isn't paying the tax, then I'm sure the people paying the tax can pay the tax themselves. No need to add a middleman.
- jedberg 8y agoThey tried that for 10 years and it didn't work. Very few people pay use tax like they should. But it wasn't cost effective to enforce every individual offender. So now they're trying something different.
- sp332 8y agoBoth you and Cerium are correct. Depending on buyers to collect sales tax from themselves hasn't been working. And forcing someone in a different jurisdiction to do it might not be defensible.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoThus forcing the businesses to pay or be punished. The business likely has the option of not passing the cost along to the consumer, but in the end they are the one being forced to pay the state.
- txsh 8y agoWrong. If you live in a state without income tax, buy a product from a company in the same state, and then ship the product to your friend in Texas, you have to pay Texas sales even though you have never been to Texas.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's because you asked the company to ship it there. That's the company collecting tax on your friend's behalf. If you buy it and ship it to yourself, and then ship it to your friend, there would be no tax, because then you bought it and they have no way of knowing it is going to your friend. Technically, your friend had to pay use tax when they got it from you. But they probably didn't. Which is why they want the retailer to collect the tax for them.
- txsh 8y agoNo. We’re talking about sales tax, not gift tax.