5 ms·
Seems pretty weak and unsupported. It can be summed up as "China doesn't excel at soccer because of authoritarianism and because the sport is not well understo
by the_af 8y ago
Seems pretty weak and unsupported.
It can be summed up as "China doesn't excel at soccer because of authoritarianism and because the sport is not well understood by anyone and central planning doesn't help".
Ok, if you say so. Where's the evidence?
- sjm-lbm 8y agoTotally agree. Just to pick a specific example and add on a bit: Germany reorganized their nationwide soccer development system in the mid-2000s to be much more centralized, and that's widely considered to be one of the reasons they have risen in prominence recently (they are the current reigning World Cup champions, for instance).
- JackFr 8y ago> one of the reasons they have risen in prominence recently Hmmmm.... From TFA: "West Germany ... won the World Cup in 1954, 1974 and 1990, and reached the final in 1966, 1982 and 1986."
- sjm-lbm 8y agoWell, there was a really bad period in between then and now. They finished last in their group in Euro 2000, and did quite badly in 2004 (though I don't remember specifics), and those were the results that motivated several changes (or, at least, moved some already-in-progress moves towards centralization forward).
- unexpected 8y agoThe Chinese women's team is actually pretty good. This is just banal political tripe. I feel like the author had a point that he wanted to make and just said anything to support it.
- oblio 8y agoThe evidence is obviously football in the USSR: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_in_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_in_the_Soviet_Union I'm being ironic, the USSR had both very strong club teams and a very strong national team.
- alxlaz 8y ago> China doesn't excel at soccer because of authoritarianism and because the sport is not well understood by anyone and central planning doesn't help It's hard not to be mean to someone who calls it soccer :-), but this betrays an obvious lack of familiarity with the history of this sport. USSR, Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia all had very strong national teams, pretty much until they were dissolved. Clubs from the communist bloc did not dominate football, but put very convincing performances and were routinely represented in the higher stages of European competitions. Red Star Belgrade and Steaua Bucharest won the Champions Cup within a few years of each other -- all this while players trained in sub-par conditions, worked with sub-par equipment, had access to sub-par medical conditions, research and treatment, and were usually unable to play abroad and further their career at the truly major European clubs. If anything, the quality of football in most ex-communist countries, Russia included, has steadily declined. Poland and Croatia are the only major and steady exceptions (Ukraine, the Czech Republic and Romania enjoyed some brief stints but not much else), and it's probably no coincidence that their national economies are faring better than those of most ex-communist countries.
- smcl 8y ago> It's hard not to be mean to someone who calls it soccer > ... Champions Cup ... People in glass houses, my friend :D
- GFischer 8y agoTo be fair, it used to be called European Champions' Cup when those teams were playing.
- smcl 8y agoNah it's not ever been called that either. It seems it was technically "European Champion Clubs' Cup" but I have literally never heard that term in my life (and I know a LOT of Celtic fans who have a lot to say about a certain night in Lisbon in 1967). Mainly my comment was just a playful "maybe don't get snippy with someone's terminology, nobody's perfect"
- 8y ago
- ashwinaj 8y agoWell put. Another stupid "Hate China" propaganda piece; no wonder people have lost faith in journalism.
- 628C6l0 8y agoYou must be Chinese spy. Burn him!
- oska 8y agoYes, it's a naked piece of propaganda.