4 ms·
One of the nice benefits of the US system of government is that the ability to relatively easily pick and choose where to live, where to work, where to do busin
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
One of the nice benefits of the US system of government is that the ability to relatively easily pick and choose where to live, where to work, where to do business, etc forces the states to compete with each other to some degree. This ruling runs counter to that because using online retailers to avoid local taxes is a very low effort way to avoid local taxes or avoid funding a local government you disagree with and this ruling paves the way for states to prevent that.
I have no problem with sales tax. I have a problem with states getting a cut of transactions that did not result in transfer of money to an entity within their borders.
Sales taxes generally follow the location where the money was received, not where the goods were used. If I buy something at a brick and mortar store then I'm subject to the sales tax where that store is located. Why should the state of buyer be getting a cut of the transaction when the state of the merchant is the one that is responsible for the environment in which that commerce happened?
If I live in MA and drive to NH and buy fireworks then MA has no claim to tax the transaction because it's obviously the environment of NH that made that commerce possible at all (you can't buy fireworks in MA). What if I live in CA and want to buy some special paint or cleaning product not for sale in CA so I drive to NV to buy it? What if I want to buy a widget and my home state taxes it and some other state subsidizes it (not necessarily at the retail level, the tax/subsidy could be anywhere in the supply chain) so much that I drive to the other state. In that case my home state still has no claim to tax the transaction since it happened out of state. What if the price is so much better elsewhere I'll be willing to pay shipping from half was across the country? How does the fact that the a 3rd party (shipping company) is responsible for getting the goods to their address change the situation? Does the fact that the transaction originates online affect anything?
I have no problem paying state sales tax as long as it goes toward the state of the merchant. The state of the merchant is responsible for creating the environment that facilitated the commerce. They should be the ones getting a cut.
Edit: I genuinely would like to know what the reasoning of those who disagree with me is. I see no good that can come from allowing states to exert authority on businesses outside their jurisdiction.
- irrational 8y agoIn what way? I choose to live in Oregon. Oregon doesn't have a sales tax. So the Supreme court ruling has no bearing on me. There is nothing stopping anyone from moving to one of the states that don't have a sales tax.
- joeldg 8y agoyou can virtually move there also, EarthClassMail has multiple mail boxes there.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoWhy do you think it's fair that online businesses are given such an advantage over physical businesses in your state?
- rconti 8y agoThe US system allows you to easily pick and choose where to live, from which where you work and where you do business generally follows. Except in the case of living close to a border (which is a bit of a hack), you generally live, work, and pay sales taxes in the same jurisdiction in which you vote and receive services. You're right that it forces states to compete with each other, which is great. Your example runs completely counter to your stated narrative. Your example is one in which you live and collect services in one place, but refuse to pay taxes to support your chosen lifestyle by instead "supporting" with your dollars a system you don't want to live under. Apparently you DO have a problem with sales tax.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]