2 ms·
yeah, every time I see "we proved this theory using a simulation..." I get a little voice in my head that says "then you didn't prove anything except your abili
by marcus_holmes 8y ago
yeah, every time I see "we proved this theory using a simulation..." I get a little voice in my head that says "then you didn't prove anything except your ability to create a simulation that agrees with your pet theory"
I understand that conducting experiments with ecosystems to prove why they behave in particular ways might be a tad tricky. But that just means that theories about ecosystems are hard to prove, not that they get a free ride to "proven".
- dalbasal 8y agoA more charitable way if putting it might be, is the simulation part of the theory or part of the evidence for it. Both are acceptable, but not at once. Simulation as theory is "safer" in a poperian sense.
- marcus_holmes 8y agogood point. The way the article presented it, the simulation clearly appears to be part of the proof. But that could be a product of the journalistic filter applied.