2 ms·
No, they don't want to be paid if you link to their content. They want you to have a licence if you reproduce their content for commercial gain. It's really im
by DanBC 8y ago
No, they don't want to be paid if you link to their content. They want you to have a licence if you reproduce their content for commercial gain.
It's really important that people who oppose this law are strictly correct when talking to their MEP, because otherwise we risk everything being ignored because of these factual errors.
- baxtr 8y agoI'm really sorry, but you can't just state these things as facts. This is your personal interpretation. The text leaves room for interpretation. For example: What is a commercial site? Is google news commercial? It is free for users. Why is a title not a preview? I know you will quote the law with the "substantial" part, but until it is not defined 100% (e.g. by courts) , everybody linking and quoting is at legal risk.
- DanBC 8y agoCommercial is really well defined: it's something you attempt to make money from. Google News is commercial. > Why is a title not a preview? I know you will quote the law with the "substantial" part, but until it is not defined 100% (e.g. by courts), everybody linking and quoting is at legal risk. Berne Convention was introduced in 1886. We've had 130 years of interpreting copyright law to find the limits of fair use. But, since you're interested in legal risk, the law attempts to clear up one area around orphaned works. > This Directive provides for rules to adapt certain exceptions and limitations to digital and cross-border environments, as well as measures to facilitate certain licensing practices as regards the dissemination of out -of-commerce works and the online availability of audiovisual works on video-on-demand platforms with a view to ensuring wider access to content. I think it's a bad law, and I've already contacted my MEP to talk about it, but I think people really need to read and understand a law before campaigning about it. When people talk about "link tax" their MEP will think "this law does no such thing, this person doesn't understand what they're talking about, I can ignore them". It's a very harmful bit of campaigning to promote the myth of a link tax.
- baxtr 8y agoI think, instead of repeating that you think it is harmful, it would sure help to hear your thoughts on the why the law is bad.
- pas 8y ago"They" sure do want to be paid. This is a policy, and a lot of people want to and will game to varying degrees. They want to extract money from others using this regulation. Sure, this sounds nice to have a license, and sure negotiating with Google et al. is very hard, and I'd be happy to help content creators somehow, but this is basically legislating the BuzzFeed model. Mo' clickz, mo' moneyz. That's a very risky deal to enshrine in law.