3 ms·
> #1 Mandatory filtering of uploaded user content. This is to prevent possible copyright infringement. There are two things that will happen: the large companie
by claudius 8y ago
> #1 Mandatory filtering of uploaded user content. This is to prevent possible copyright infringement. There are two things that will happen: the large companies will generate upload filter mechanism that won’t work perfectly so they will deny many uploads. Smaller companies won’t be able sustain an upload functionality. Thanks for killing innovation and supporting large monopolies
I find this actually quite good. Companies accepting "user uploaded content" are mostly entirely pointless, cost a lot of bandwidth and unnecessarily centralise yet another part of our lives. Anything which harms them will effectively be a net positive.
> #2 Link Tax: publishers want to be compensated if you link to their content. This is to prevent google and the like to profit from publishers content without “paying” for it. This is totally absurd. Again, two things will happen: large corporations will stop linking to publishers site (see how google Spain stopped their news offering) and second everybody posting links online publically will become an outlaw.
Note that it’s not a link tax but a tax to use snippets of the article. You’re quite fine linking to an article, but reproducing parts of it won’t be ok. Right now this is already a somewhat grey area and, again, it won’t exactly hurt anyone but the right people.
So, sure, this is some extra burden yadda yadda, but mostly it will just limit pointless business activities sucking up bandwidth.
- baxtr 8y ago> Companies accepting "user uploaded content" are mostly entirely pointless You just uploaded user content to HN... well. You’re quite fine linking to an article, but reproducing parts of it won’t be ok. This is a link in HTML: <a href="URL" title="link title" target="link target">link label</a> The "link lable" is a preview/snippet of content. If I a quote 1-2 sentences from the article, it is a snippet. Where do you draw the line?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 8y agoIf the article is a one or two sentence article then you can't quote all of it. If you've quoted an insubstantial portion then the law already says that's ok.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Companies accepting "user uploaded content" are mostly entirely pointless Is this user-uploaded content to Hacker News intended to be ironic?