4 ms·
> I don't often say nice things about GWB's administration but one thing that came out of their terrorist paranoia was that they managed to basically kill the t
by wahern 8y ago
> I don't often say nice things about GWB's administration but one thing that came out of their terrorist paranoia was that they managed to basically kill the tax haven status of Switzerland
That seems like it could have been a counter-productive strategy. Better that your enemies use a well-understood banking system with [theoretically] reliable and consistent bookkeeping than for those transactions to shift to a more disperse, more chaotic international system. Even if Swiss accounts were nominally secret, AFAIU the CIA and NSA had developed a fairly reliable system for snooping around.
There's a reason New York and London continue to be world leaders in processing financial transactions--the governments have been intentionally tolerant of shady characters, shady businesses, and shady nations as long as the transactions nominally followed the law. Among other benefits, that puts you in a good position to keep track of the bad guys and, when it really counts, to take them down. If you police too heavily all that activity goes somewhere else.
But it does leave you open to accusations of aiding & abetting bad behavior. There's a limit to what can be politically and legally tolerated in New York and London. But you can structure the international system to channel those intolerable transactions to the least worse alternatives.
Like so much with the War on Terror, the better approach would be to improve HUMINT and investigatory resources, rather than pushing the activity further underground and playing a game of whack-a-mole.
- everdev 8y agoI don't think it takes long for word to spread. Once privacy is comprised your window of opportunity probably closes pretty quickly. Even a hint of government access to Swiss accounts probably sent all nefarious accounts somewhere else.
- wahern 8y agoSwiss banks were still used for the 1MDB operation, which involved Saudi Arabian intermediaries who 1) presumably understood the limits to Swiss secrecy and 2) probably ran in the same circles as those associated with militant organizations. And that began after the Bush administration. Moving transactions to other systems is also risky for the bad guys, in terms of higher transaction costs and less predictability regarding the degree of confidentiality. It's like in computer security--you can't defend against an omnipotent attacker, rather you have to make some assumptions about your visibility and desirability as a target vs the strength of defenses. Choosing to go with some new, untested service may make you invisible or may leave you a sitting duck; how can you know? Moreover, while organizations like Al Qaeda would have steered absolutely clear of the normal system, they benefit when more money moves via the darkest channels. They benefit from improved consistency, reliability, liquidity, and cover traffic.
- Iv 8y agoTo be fair I take this as a gain as I see tax haven as a much more harmful thing than Al-Quaeda ever was. It is an enabler not only of terrorism but of several crimes that causes a countless amount of death globally. And no, I don't buy the "we tolerate it so that we could watch it". Too much private money is at odds there. The truth is that this still exists because otherwise there would be no channel for the Saud family to fund the Bush one or for Russian oligarchs to pay up GOP members.
- wahern 8y agoExcept the crackdown has arguably led to faster evolution of tax havenry. Over the past 15 years the traditional tax havens have lost considerable business to new jurisdictions offering more complex and cheaper havens (e.g. trusts and property schemes), attracting smaller customers (e.g. small-time multi-millionaires) who previously couldn't have afforded to indulge in these activities. The market has grown. That was inevitable to some extent but when your achilles heel is your ability to respond to change (which government agencies suck at) it's a risky strategy to shake-up the system.
- Iv 8y agoIt is natural that it tries to evolve, this is an enemy with more resources than the US army. We wont kill it with one attempt. We need to keep continue still. In my opinion, leaks have been the best tool so far: it adds a risk to tax evasion that is kind of new. Every added cost or added risk is welcomed. And people usually hate when I mention that, but I am fairly convinced that most of the value of bitcoin comes from people desiring to move huge funds discreetly and efficiently between accounts. It probably made the whole industry move faster than countries' regulations.
- al_chemist 8y ago> tax haven (...) causes a countless amount of death globally. Care to elaborate?
- jacobush 8y ago