7 ms·
The most expensive four words in the English language: “This time is different”
- ericnyamu 8y agoFirst
- anonytrary 8y agoExpensive? On the contrary, Facebook appears to have made money with these four words -- time and again.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- taneq 8y agoDepends on the amount of optimism expressed by the phrase. As the saying goes, "no-one ever went broke overestimating human stupidity."
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoThe edited title was a bit confusing to read for me. I would've found it easier to see it reversed: The Four Most Expensive Words in the English Language: "This time is different" Anyway, on to the actual topic... I need to sit down to give this more thought, but I still think there's value in P2P networks, and it's worth pursuing. You should be able to easily replicate and share content that you care about. The big incentive is being able to keep your own copy and being able to do whatever you want with it. How many times have you tried searching for an old YouTube video, only to find it got taken down? Another example: package managers! You want to have a machine-local cache, a remote cache for reproducible builds and deployments, and whatever other remotes you get the original packages from. Maybe different registries have varying content policies, and you can pick your favorites. If you have a few developers in an office it's a lot faster to grab dependencies from the laptop of the person sitting next to you than a CDN.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xemasiv 8y ago> I need to sit down to give this more thought, but I still think there's value in P2P networks, and it's worth pursuing. My argument against this is just because it's purely peer-to-peer, it doesn't always directly mean it's an overall improvement in the user experience. > You should be able to easily replicate and share content that you care about. Yes there is definitely value in that, I even agree with there! But I personally think turning the whole thing into a completely peer-to-peer approach isn't the answer. It's the raw shit problems about bandwidth capability and network latency which really matters - which, if you've tried streaming from utorrent/bittorrent before, it's very obvious that the experience is still greatly affected by the lack of a little centralization that YouTube has. > The big incentive is being able to keep your own copy and being able to do whatever you want with it. How many times have you tried searching for an old YouTube video, only to find it got taken down? Neutral on this, very nuanced since most of the time it involves legal issues and opinionated perspectives, lol.
- smolder 8y agoThe lack of upstream bandwidth offered by cable providers almost seems deliberate. (I.e. a disinterest in improving the upstream capabilities of docsis standards, as well as offering pitiful upstream bandwidth in their plans.)
- zeth___ 8y agoWhat you're talking about is the difference between an ecology and a monoculture. The reason why we don't see monocultures in nature is because they put every single one of their members at risk of sudden death. A single pathogen can wipe them out. The exhaustion of resources required to sustain them can starve them. The build up of by products can kill them. Think of a medieval town drowning in excrement, running out of top soil and about to get hit by the plague. An ecology on the other hand puts none of their members at risk by virtue of their existence because they are diluted. Think of a band of hunter gatherers, they might individually die at 40, be exposed to ebola and worse, but the fact they are so widely separated and so few means that they have few if any vulnerabilities that can kill the whole tribe. The reason why we see monocultures now is because they are more efficient and our time horizons are tiny. Amazon will fail catastrophically. Billions or trillions will be lost. No one will learn anything because it's cheaper not to than to build a really resilient network.
- toxicFork 8y agoThere are a number of assumptions being made about "P2", for example: > a peer stores a single copy Why? You can have multiple peers store your data and I can argue that this will be even more competitive in price. > they need to implement their own erasure coding to compensate for the lack of redundancy at the service. But you can have redundancy at the service. > P2's pricing will be volatile This is unexplained.
- akanet 8y agoThese assertions are descriptions of the current set of crypto P2P storage systems. Peers only store one copy of your data, per peer. Of course, multiple peers will store copies of your data or the system could never work, but there isn't too much incentive for any one peer to store two copies of your data. Price volatility for these systems is already a fact, and it's unlikely that any crypto could match AWS' historical price predictability of "monotonically decreasing".
- airbreather 8y agoI thought the four most expensive words in the English language were "will you marry me".
- bartread 8y agoEither those, or "Let's have a baby."
- auggierose 8y agoUsually that one works without words.
- xemasiv 8y agoOr "I'm two months delayed"
- Cthulhu_ 8y ago"Make America great again"
- ozim 8y agoMy vote goes on "Hold my beer"
- bittermang 8y ago"Launch all the nukes"
- uberman 8y agoParticularly with respect to war, my vote is: "It worked last time".
- xemasiv 8y agoGreat post, I dig it. But I'm fucking wondering why there isn't an option to subscribe to future posts / your site in general.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoWhat do you mean? There's an RSS available: https://blog.dshr.org/feeds/posts/default?alt=rss https://blog.dshr.org/feeds/posts/default?alt=rss
- frabcus 8y agoI think the main thing that this misses is the potential benefit of an open protocol. We still don't have a standard open equivalent of Dropbox.js (deprecated). That is, a user controlled account which a browser or phone knows about that can store files, and that every app that needs to store files can read and write to. Proprietary solutions and B2B solutions will never meet that need - it needs to be something that all the big tech companies can get behind, and which consumers have visibility and control of. I can't see a route to such a protocol right now, in terms of either technology or finance, other than something open source and based on a cryptocurrency. As such, I hope one of them succeeds. Even if all the files end up stored in Amazon, at least the protocol will be open and everything will be encrypted. And you will be able to trivially as a consumer store the data on a competitor (Microsoft, Google, Baidu), or on your own server if you want or need (countries and companies and people at risk of human rights violations may care).
- frabcus 8y agoTo show this is possible: Note how ubiquitous git is now as such a filesystem and protocol for developers. Remember how that has come about over the last 10 years. Imagine the same thing happening with a consumer targetted file storage system and protocol.
- ksk 8y agogit is popular because of many external factors, some of which (github gitlab, etc) are centralized closed systems. I don't think git by itself would have become popular. I'd say that in today's world, you need someone somewhere making mad cash for a protocol to become that popular. Could an open storage protocol achieve that?
- regularfry 8y agoI honestly don't see the need for it to be distributed. A zeroconf home file server that handled giving you access when you were out and about would solve the 80% problem.
- acdha 8y agoI don’t think it’s missing so much as being realistic about the costs of developing a production grade service. Cryptocurrencies aren’t really up to that since it’s unlikely to lead to the kind of lottery returns VCs are chasing — the most people are going to pay is capped at Dropbox/iCloud/etc. rates — and the volatility makes it hard to sustain years of development to make something stable enough to trust and easy to use.
- Theodores 8y agoThe points made in this article remind me of how CD-ROM was adopted in the early nineties. Once upon a time CD-ROM was new and with Windows for Workgroups you could share a given CD-ROM across a network. If you needed to install $SOFTWARE on machine B you could theoretically put the CD-ROM in machine A's drive and install from there. The person on machine A might even put the right disk in for you. Given that CD-ROM drives cost a reasonable amount of money at the time and probably went at 3x speed, you would have a financial incentive to specify machine B without the CD-ROM, same with machine C and machine D. In so doing you could save enough money to buy machine E (or at least the monitor for it). Nobody went down this route, in offices or in education. In education settings there were financial incentives to save money plus tech savvy staff on hand to make it work smoothly. There was no 'status' value in having the CD-ROM attached. Everyone was okay about sharing the same printer but not the same CD-ROM drive. You would not even need the CD-ROM as often as a printer in those days. The publishing industry was in its infancy and you only really had install media. Writeable media was a long way off. Surely it would have made sense to have your MS-Office install media or 'Encarta' available to all, on the network which was faster than the CD-ROM drives of the era? Yet this never happened. Instead every machine was specified with the CD-ROM. Disks were passed around much like floppies were. Nobody network-shared their CD-ROM drives. Yet all that was needed was a 'right click' and 'share'. The financial aspect in doing so was not a micro-payment in some alt-coin it was proper $$$ saved from not having to purchase another CD-ROM drive. In time the $999 CD-ROM drives went to 4x and cost nearer $200, then they became 52x and cost nearer $100 to eventually become the $20 things bundled with every machine. When writeable CD-ROMS and DVDs came along the storage space was vast compared to HDDs of the time yet still there was no network sharing of the things, everyone had their own disk in their own machine. Sure there were exceptions - network machines of the time - but these were the exceptions. For the same reasons of capitalism and human nature I suspect that file-sharing-by-altcoin will fail. Moore's Law makes 'common sense' arguments for file sharing in a P2P way where you rent out your disk not make sense. Layer on top the fact that every alt-coin is a scam-coin and you know that P2P file-coins are only for the true believers.
- yial 8y agoI remember being in grade school, and we networked (shared) the drive on the one computer - only because the cd-rom drives on the other ones were broken and we wanted to play/ install Warcraft.
- bhouston 8y ago> But that's not the worst of it. Suppose P2 storage became profitable and started to take business from S3. Amazon's slow AI has an obvious response, it can run P2 peers for itself on the same infrastructure as it runs S3. With its vast economies of scale and extremely low cost of capital, P2-on-S3 would easily capture the bulk of the P2 market. It isn't just that, if successful, the P2 network would become centralized, it is that it would become centralized at Amazon! That is exactly what I said about a year ago, although I predicted centralization on BackBlaze instead of S3 because they had lower costs: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14988800 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14988800
- filecoinp2throw 8y agoI disagree with his argument that for anyone to use P2P storage, it has to be less expensive than S3. It's true that this will be hard to do, for all the reasons he listed. But some amount of people will be willing to pay a premium for P2P storage, because it can't be censored or ordered to be deleted as easily as data stored on S3. Pirates, journalists, and activists will appreciate this use case. There's also another economic reason for why people would pay extra to use P2P storage. I'm sure there's some sort of term for this, but many people have stacks of cryptocurrencies that they can't or don't want to exchange for their day-to-day currency. Maybe their government restricts exchanges, the funds came from a questionable source, they have some philosophical issue with "fiat" currency, or they're just avoiding taxes. If you need to store 50TB of data, and have $900 in your checking account and 400 ETH in your wallet, you'd probably choose P2P storage over S3.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"It's true that this will be hard to do, for all the reasons he listed. But some amount of people will be willing to pay a premium for P2P storage, because it can't be censored or ordered to be deleted as easily as data stored on S3." Some will, but most won't. "Pirates, journalists, and activists will appreciate this use case." Journalists are probably the only group among those that would have the money to spend on it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- csomar 8y agoNo P2P storage networks have succeeded? What about torrents? It is a huge market.
- jasode 8y ago>No P2P storage networks have succeeded? What about torrents? You have to look at the specific context his essay is about. Torrents are popular for data that many participants desire such as "StarWars_1080p.mp4" and "LadyGaga_album.mp3". Torrents do not work for a 500GB encrypted backup of "JohnDoe_personal_vacation_photos_20180621.zip". There's no financial incentive for others to download and store it so the number of seeeds/peers will be 0. His essay is not about a p2p version of Netflix or Spotify (e.g. bittorrent or Napster). He's talking about a p2p version of "cloud storage" such as BackBlaze/AmazonS3/DropBox for storing data that may only be important to that user. That's why he's dissecting Filecoin and its economics.
- ksk 8y agoBecause torrents are not a storage network. Even ignoring the read-only aspect of it, there is no way to ensure that someone will download your torrent.
- rince 8y agoThe actual quote is (according to Wikipedia and “understanding what you’re trying to say”) - “This time IT’S different”
- pressurefree 8y agoendless comparables fallacy.
- 79357423 8y ago"Take all my money" Here I made it better.