4 ms·
I was hoping CRISPR/Cas9 (or some similar system) was going to answer many prayers. Maybe this means it's less likely?
by jcims 8y ago
I was hoping CRISPR/Cas9 (or some similar system) was going to answer many prayers. Maybe this means it's less likely?
- Analemma_ 8y agoI imagine CRISPR/Cas9 still has great potential for addressing specific genetic disorders (which are usually localized to a single, known gene), but the more transhumanist stuff about making smarter, longer-lived people is still a ways off.
- meowface 8y agoI don't think this significantly changes expectations. CRISPR and similar systems will still be immensely beneficial for simple traits (e.g. traits determined by a very small number of genes). Some diseases can be eliminated by changing a single gene. CRISPR and similar systems could someday be helpful for dealing with complex traits, but we first need to understand exactly what genes contribute to them and how, and for many traits, that will take a very long time. In some sense, CRISPR is just a dumb cutting tool. Knowing where to cut was always the hard part, and it always will be.
- empath75 8y agoEven if the cause of a particular disorder is spread across the genome it could be the case that changing one particular gene is enough to cure it in some cases.
- polski-g 8y agoNo it just means more than one gene would be needed to be modified. Don't know who was ever thinking that traits weren't polygenic. If they were monogenic then there would be no variance in traits.