3 ms·
A hawk that eats a cute baby bunny is an asshole too right? My cat when it knocks over a bunch of stuff in the house chasing a mouse creates a local environment
by phkahler 8y ago
A hawk that eats a cute baby bunny is an asshole too right? My cat when it knocks over a bunch of stuff in the house chasing a mouse creates a local environmental mess. Humans are just better at this stuff than anything that's come before. Bacteria will consume all the food in a dish until their ecosystem collapses. Algae blooms happen and do the same thing. Again, humans are just doing this better and on a larger scale.
Having said that, it would be in our long term interest not to continue doing this until the system collapses.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoYou're responding to an imagined foe. See how you go with a "nature does it too, you're an environmentalist that wants to protect cute widdle animals" angle? That's because you're categorizing your opponent into a known bucket without actually pausing to consider their argument. This is a good way to efficiently comment on social media, but this style of dialogue will never either convince them that they're wrong or convince you that you're wrong. All it will do is reinforce itself by giving your brain a brief jolt of self-satisfaction.
- phkahler 8y ago>> That's because you're categorizing your opponent into a known bucket... I actually assessed my opponent as someone who has it in for mankind, not an environmentalist (that's your word BTW and doesn't belong in quotes you attribute to me). My point wasn't so much "nature does it to" but rather to illustrate - humans are part of nature and their behavior is not unique. To keep us separate from nature seems to be either human-hating or human-aggrandizing. Given the OPs calling us assholes I figure we can guess which. From there I was most definitely having more fun than trying to making a point!
- xtian 8y ago> Having said that, it would be in our long term interest not to continue doing this until the system collapses. You’ve stumbled through the straw men and into the point, my dude. The way of thinking which frames humans as “best animals” is the same one which makes us incapable of averting suicide by ecological collapse. Consciousness is not just a cool survival trick, it’s a responsibility.
- perl4ever 8y agoConsciousness is not a collective attribute of humans. I find it strange that people have discussions in which some sort of collective consciousness is implicitly assumed. You're arguing, so you're obviously individuals! If we had a collective mind, we wouldn't be disagreeing. It's as though we were a bunch of single cells arguing about whether we should become a multicellular life form to avoid us all dying. It might in theory be necessary, but it would involve all members giving up autonomy and being willing to act and die on command. That raises two questions - is it really worth it, and is it possible? I'm not firmly pro or con organizing humanity into a "super organism" to avoid ecological disaster - I'm just saying this is what people are ultimately debating wrt global warming, and it's pretty "out there". I'm not convinced it's feasible, at least not in the near future (next century).
- xtian 8y agoWhat?