3 ms·
> They knew that what they were doing was immoral on some level but it was framed in a way where an individual who struggled with what they had to do and did it
by smacktoward 8y ago
> They knew that what they were doing was immoral on some level but it was framed in a way where an individual who struggled with what they had to do and did it anyway was perceived as a "real man" because he would put the good of the people's community over his own feelings. Hence, when Himmler describes the Holocaust in his Posen speech, he highlights that despite the hard mission that had been given to them by history, they had always remained civilized (anständig). This is a particular nefarious aspect of these mechanism of ideological framing: Wherein overcoming doubt in the face of cruel acts becomes a virtue.
When Gina Haspel was nominated to be the Director of the CIA, I was struck by the inadvertent echo of this in so many defenses of her involvement in the Agency's black-site "enhanced interrogation" (aka torture) program. Her defenders argued that this experience actually said positive things about her, since she only tortured people when ordered to by the President, and stopped doing so the moment those orders stopped coming. In other words, torturing people didn't turn her into the sort of person who tortures people. She remained civilized.
Putting aside the obvious objection that Nuremberg should have eliminated "she was just following orders" as a valid defense for all time, it was remarkable how willing even people like Democratic Senators were to separate the act of having tortured people from the idea of what a torturer looks like. Just having tortured people isn't enough to make you a torturer anymore.