3 ms·
They aren't "causing" the problems, though. They are, at most, selecting a manifestation. But if they out of the goodness of their heart cut prices, there's sti
by jerf 8y ago
They aren't "causing" the problems, though. They are, at most, selecting a manifestation. But if they out of the goodness of their heart cut prices, there's still a housing shortage, the underlying problem that will manifest one way or another.
If "housing shortage" sounds neutral or preferable to you, try to imagine the human-interest sob stories that would be written about how long-time residents are preventing anyone from moving in, or how unfair it is that this person got one of the underpriced slots ("a white male Facebook engineer from out east") and this other person ("disadvantaged resident whose family has been in the area for two hundred years") didn't. To the extent the problem is "Stop sob stories being written about Silicon Valley", trading high rents for a housing shortage didn't solve the problem, just moved it around.
Or how upset a lot of people would be if Facebook just leaves because they can't get enough housing.
Cutting prices would also reduce the motivation for others to figure out how to build more housing, because the higher the rents get the bigger the prize is for building more housing.
Trying to use price fixing to mask underlying problems has a long track record of failing to fix the underlying problem, and then creating problems of its own.
(To be honest, "Facebook leaving" or some equivalently sized employer is the only real solution that's ever going to work out. I think a good case can be made that Silicon Valley the business is now simply physically too big to fit into Silicon Valley the geography. Even if density was increased to the requisite levels, that would cause its own problems that people would be complaining about with air quality, even worse traffic, etc.)