7 ms·
I'm not too worried about this one. This will just mean platforms will not link to publishers. EVER It already failed in Spain and Germany, they will just sho
by raverbashing 8y ago
I'm not too worried about this one.
This will just mean platforms will not link to publishers. EVER
It already failed in Spain and Germany, they will just shoot themselves in the foot again.
- visarga 8y agoI wrote a Romanian news concentrator as a hobby project, guess I will have to put it down now. They were 99% bullshit anyway - clickbait and fake news. That's what they are protecting.
- v_lisivka 8y agoWhy not just use URL shortener outside of EU?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CloudNetworking 8y agoWould you fund the lawsuits they'll get?
- manfredo 8y agoIf the link shortener is operated by an entity outside the EU is it still subject to EU law?
- CloudNetworking 8y agoYou'll get the lawsuit, not the link shortener.
- visarga 8y agoIf I use the article title and main image thumbnail I might still be under legal restrictions.
- alfredallan1 8y agoSo does this mean *this HN post is illegal because it links to a news article?
- ernesth 8y agoNo. According to the so called link-tax article, it is not linking but putting content that makes a platform liable. So this HN post would not be illegal because of the link, but maybe because of the title that was "stolen" from the publisher. The aim is at news.google.com and other search engines and news aggregators that include a blurb coming from the article along the link. To be honest, it is not yet clear if they intend for the title to be taxed or not.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> it is not linking but putting content that makes a platform liable All the comments quoting content would be taxable, though.
- ahel 8y ago> All the comments quoting content would be taxable, though. Like this one.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Like this one Not quite. My previous comment linked to another comment. I don't believe that would be covered by this copyright proposal. What would be covered would be a HN user posting a link to an EU publication, my reading it, and then quoting from a portion of it. The simplest fix appears to be banning linking to EU publications.
- alfredallan1 8y agoI don’t usually try to deliberately ask stupid questions, but I can’t help myself in this instance. What counts as a EU publication? The author residing in the EU? Someone with a special “publisher” license? The author possessing EU citizenship? EU readership? .eu domain name? The domain registrar? The physical servers of the web hosting service? The backup service? What about those that use cloud services who have their physical infrastructure spread out wherever? And various combinations of the above… Lastly, how would checking any of these be implemented by the software that’s supposed to be scanning for content that could possibly be in violation?
- sebst 8y agoFalse. They will shoot themselves in the foot, yes. But at least in Germany, Google is the only entity which was granted a free "licence" by the collecting society. This puts Google in a better place than any other news aggregator.
- pas 8y agoAny lawsuit in progress with regards to that?
- Filligree 8y agoIt's not illegal, so that would require a law change. Which is what this article is about.
- pas 8y agoIt sounds very much like discrimination - if no other aggregator / news site gets the same treatment.
- sebst 8y agoInteresting argument. Because this is the same anti-trust argument the publishers used against Google: "Google has monopolistic power, so they should be obliged to list our content (and then, pay)". On that argument the Spanish version of the copyright law, Google decided to shut down News for Spain completely.
- drak0n1c 8y agoEven the most well-intentioned regulations often end up benefitting the largest and most entrenched industry players. The term is "regulatory capture".
- merinowool 8y agoIn Spain they _had to_ link to publishers, so Google has shut down their service.
- gpvos 8y agoNo, the problem was that publishers were not permitted to grant free licenses.