2 ms·
While I have a problem with revoking citizenship of naturalized citizens. I don't see why there can't be other effective means to persecute someone who gained
by eesmith 8y ago
While I have a problem with revoking citizenship of naturalized citizens.
I don't see why there can't be other effective means to persecute someone who gained citizenship fraudulently.
The article give an example of the problem with the argument that "The lie must be material for this logic to hold, that is, a lie where if you told the truth, citizenship would not have been granted."
In the 1980s, immigration law prohibited people with "sexual deviation", and homosexuality was considered a sexual deviation. Suppose I were a homosexual man in the 1980s, and I lied about it in my application, and gained US citizenship. Now it's 2018, and homosexuality is no longer considered a sexual deviation that could keep someone from emigrating to the US.
Why should that lie - which would have kept citizenship from being granted in the 1980s - mean that I should be stripped of citizenship now?