3 ms·
tldr: I'll be in favor of cracking down on illegal immigrants when people stop hiring them for fear of getting in trouble. This is a naive reading of the polit
by sanderjd 8y ago
tldr: I'll be in favor of cracking down on illegal immigrants when people stop hiring them for fear of getting in trouble.
This is a naive reading of the politics. Very few people are actively in favor of illegal immigration. Many people believe the cures (that is, the ones that politicians push for) are worse than the disease. My personal view is that if we really wanted to solve the problem, we would do it on the economic side; there are whole sectors of our economy that everyone knows are propped up by the employment of illegal immigrants. Nobody talks about that because the people who benefit most are strong, organized, and relatable (upstanding well-to-do businesspeople). Instead, everyone goes after the weak, disorganized, and unrelatable (scary foreigners who don't even speak our language).
- ethagnawl 8y ago> Nobody talks about that because the people who benefit most are strong, organized, and relatable (upstanding well to do business people). People who own hotels and golf courses, for instance.
- izendejas 8y agoThis. If you really want to stop illegal immigration you go after employers who hire them. But even our president is content with hiring them, just not treating them like humans with certain inalienable rights.
- jcims 8y agoWhat would the process look like for authenticating individuals that wish to work for your company? Or maybe more precisely, what would meet the burden of proof for any reasonable regulation around such a thing? This would just drive up the value of stolen identities and make illegal immigrants even more indentured to organized criminals that supply them with such.
- sanderjd 8y agoYeah, this is definitely the best counterargument on this point. I do agree that it's very difficult, but it's not like the other alternatives are easy in any way (see the current debacle as exhibit A). If I heard politicians talking about how they've tried and failed to attack this side of the question in different ways, I may be more sympathetic to the alternatives. The deafening silence on this point makes me very skeptical.
- jcims 8y agoIt's just a very difficult problem to solve. The drug war has proven you can't just rely on enforcement with laws that run across the economic grain. You need to find a way to align them, and that will take time and massive commitment. Unfortunately we're not collectively interested in that, we're far more interested in proving the other side wrong. On a side note, a few well-told and politically neutral stories out of Hollywood wouldn't hurt here. We'll likely have immigration solved before we could actually expect that, but a guy can dream.
- sanderjd 8y agoYeah I think we agree on all counts. Except that maybe I'm a bit more surprised than you are that people aren't collectively interested in putting in the commitment to actually solve a problem.
- burfog 8y agoPut aside the illegal aliens for the moment. What about all the US citizens who might use stolen identities? For example, one of your workers disappears and you discover that they walked off with $millions worth of your stuff. You report this grand theft, giving the police the supposed identity. The police later tell you that this person died 3 years before you hired him. For example, you hire somebody who uses a stolen identity to pass your background check. They just got out of prison for beating their previous boss to death. For example, you hire a supposed professional with some sort of certification. They might claim to be a doctor, a Professional Engineer, a lawyer, or a Certified Public Accountant. By identity theft, they convince you that your business can depend on them to meet legal requirements and do competent work. Correct identity is rather important.
- jcims 8y agoI'm not contesting the importance of correct identity. My point is that there are limited facilities available to authenticate the identity of any given human, and that if we increase the value of being able to identify as a known American, we'll increase the criminal interest in bestowing that upon those that are able to pay for it.
- undersuit 8y agoThe reason stolen identities are used is because our current processes to allow immigrants to work are purposely limited. Allow any immigrant to declare themselves. Give them an immigrant specific id so that they can go to an employer and work legally while paying local, state, and federal taxes. Keeping the system closed is what allows exploitation. Stolen identities are needed to work in the closed system else the boss needs to break the law, and plenty of employers do just that.
- jcims 8y agoNo argument from me, but we're switching topics from holding employers accountable for the identity of the people they hire.
- undersuit 8y agoI don't think I made any such switch. In fact by opening up and not artificially limiting supply of permits or immigrant work ids you massively reduce the need to hold employers accountable. Right now the employers are held accountable in many cases. They are the first line of defense to make sure someone we have decided is an illegal immigrant and not allowed to work in the US, doesn't work. We selectively enforce this behavior with laws that punish businesses that allow illegals to work.