3 ms·
Stop. Being. Fatalistic. FFS. You are not helping, you are making things worse. No, we do not NEED Net Neutrality. The internet can/has/will survived for the s
by exabrial 8y ago
Stop. Being. Fatalistic. FFS. You are not helping, you are making things worse.
No, we do not NEED Net Neutrality. The internet can/has/will survived for the short ~2ish years of really weak NN that was easily circumnavigable by corporate lawyers. The last form of NN we had allows Comcasts of the USA to legalize their local monopolies.
The solution is multifaceted. First, if we want to break free of the stranglehold, we need to lower the barrier of entry into the market for new ISPs, not raise it. Second, the FTC needs to examine the practice of "up to 50mbps" advertising and "internet service" vs "information service". Strict definitions of these would help us along. Third, vague definitions of "service abusers" needs to be eliminated or defined. If they are selling you "unlimited internet", then there is in fact, no limit. If you hit a limit by an ISP, they need to be reported in your bill when and where the policy violation took place, plus allow for a dispute process. Finally, there are a lot more dirty things ISPs are doing, like Verizon injecting HTTP headers that identify an account to advertisers.
The 2015 NN laws were too weak to accomplish what they sought out to do. I'm happy they're gone so we can possibly get some effective regulations in.
- TheGRS 8y agoIs there a reason to believe that getting rid of a regulation actually fosters in better regulations? I don't think I follow that logic.
- btilly 8y agoRegulations tend to follow abuse. The more egregious the abuse, the stronger the regulation. Therefore a strong regulation can follow deregulation. Of course the opposite can happen. Deregulation can shift the Overton window to the point where regulations that once seemed reasonable are off the table. As an example, even most of the people complaining about growing inequality between rich and poor aren't openly suggesting a return to pre-Reagan top tax rates of 70%.
- Latteland 8y agoTotally agree. Net neutrality would prevent comcast from blocking the traffic of a new internet provider. That post is like a clever but evil posting from a corporate pr flack for comcast. net neutrality should help new internet providers.
- vel0city 8y ago> we need to lower the barrier of entry into the market for new ISPs Running the last mile cabling is inherently naturally monopolistic. How many companies run power lines to your house? How many companies run sewer lines to your house? Water mains? Ultimately, we either need to have highly regulated last-mile providers (strong net neutrality/common carrier/title II) or have municipal last mile providers. Personally I'd love to see a system like ERCOT[0] implemented. Last mile gets contracted out to some company a little over cost with regulations about ensuring capacity growth is planned for, while power delivery is handled by retail electric providers. Your home gets connected to some exchange a few miles away. You want to go through Comcast's network? Just give them the info off the ONT. Want to switch providers? Log into the other provider's website, give them your information, a routing change gets pushed out, and suddenly your packets are going out through CenturyLink or anyone else at the exchange. In reality its the last mile that's highly monopolistic, in most metro areas of the US there are probably at least half a dozen transit providers out there. They just don't want to spend the money digging trenches to everyone's homes to get 10% of the population of the area. > the FTC needs to examine the practice of "up to 50mbps" I'd really hope not, at least not too aggressively. I greatly prefer my best-effort 100Mbps fiber internet for $30 a month compared to the hundreds of dollars a month for SLA-backed 100Mbit fiber at my office. If they had to guarantee service, you'd see much slower average speeds offered to consumers at higher prices. Oversubscription of capacity is how residential internet gives us such high speeds when we're downloading a 100GB game randomly in the evening for not a lot of money. If you want an SLA, pay for the SLA. There are plenty of us that are fine with all the speed most of the time, with sometimes being a bit slower. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_Reliability_Council_of_Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_Reliability_Council_o...
- exabrial 8y ago> at least not too aggressively. Oh for sure! Maybe I overstated my point. Reasonable best efforts play a huge part in making affordable residential service. But right now, there's no way for a consumer to compare what's realistic, driving down competition, because they "assume they're all the same"
- bkor 8y ago> No, we do not NEED Net Neutrality. The internet can/has/will survived for the short ~2ish years of really weak NN Net neutrality was in place much longer than this. Furthermore, there were put in place because companies continuously started to abuse them. > need to lower the barrier of entry into the market for new ISPs, not raise it That has nothing to do with net neutrality. Treating everything pretty much the same is way easier than building complicated billing systems.