4 ms·
> Big cities never seem content to let public transit compete with cars on a level playing field. You're right. We need to insist that drivers pay as much for
by jcranmer 8y ago
> Big cities never seem content to let public transit compete with cars on a level playing field.
You're right. We need to insist that drivers pay as much for their privilege to use public roads as we insist that public transit users pay to use public transit.
> See the highly inefficient HOV lanes, the purposeful underdevelopment of roads, exorbitant parking prices, punitive fuel and car taxes, closure of lanes, and so forth.
Oh. You want the government to subsidize your car-centric lifestyle even more than it does so. SOV cars have very large demands on space, and in urban settings, space is at a premium. Free parking, or even mandatory parking minimums, are essentially taxing everyone for the benefit of drivers.
The normal "user fees" for roads--gas taxes and car taxes--simply do not cover the actual costs even of maintenance for roads, let alone the capital costs of expanding them. This means that those funds come from general revenue, again causing everyone to subsidize drivers, whether or not they actually use them.
- marcoperaza 8y agoI see your point, and it’s a very valid observation. But I think it’s different when the overwhelming majority of people want cars and want to live in the suburbs. Organizing public goods to serve the collective desires of the vast majority is different than socially engineering society by forcing them to abandon their preferred way of life because a powerful minority thinks it’s backwards and unenlightened.
- ocschwar 8y agoPeople might "want cars and want to live in the suburbs." That does not mean that my city should be torn apart with freeways to accommodate them.
- francisofascii 8y agoMaybe you are right, but I would challenge the assumption that the overwhelming majority of people want cars and want to live in the suburbs. Many lament having to live there, but have little choice due to factors such as cost, schools, crime, etc. It is interesting to see how many American's choose for vacation, a high density hotel, condos, cruises, etc. Maybe Americans prefer living in villages and higher density communities more than people realize.