4 ms·
> Access to US consumers is a big bargaining chip Which is why finished consumer products are not part of the new tariffs, so companies that make stuff in Chin
by detaro 8y ago
> Access to US consumers is a big bargaining chip
Which is why finished consumer products are not part of the new tariffs, so companies that make stuff in China and ship it to the US are better off than companies buying parts in China and assembling in the US? Or was there a big push of end-product tariffs before that didn't make headlines?
In most cases, buying all your parts locally is fairly impractical. (The documentation of various "fair trade" electronics projects is often interesting in that regard, since they often are willing to accept higher prices from trustworthy local sources, and often find that only a few things can be gotten locally at all, and often only in specialist variants, e.g. high-precision parts, with matching prices). Maybe it'll be enough push to restart some component industries, but I'm skeptical.
- IanDrake 8y agoI think you’re making an assumption that the ongoing trade negotiations is static. It’s not. Today it’s parts, tomorrow it could be fully assembled goods. If you’re going to negotiate, you don’t play all your cards at once. I don’t think the end state of the negotiations is protectionist tariffs for the US, it’s to get China to drop their protectionist tariffs. If we reach that end goal, how is that a bad thing?
- detaro 8y agoIt just seems odd to put tariffs on things that'll hurt local industries and make life harder for companies that have moved at least some production steps into your country (after lots of talk to encourage companies to do that, and apparently at least some successes doing that) over those that operate entirely outside. > I don’t think the end state of the negotiations is protectionist tariffs for the US We'll see, at least some of the recent tariffs seem to be exactly that, e.g. the steel and aluminium tariffs against the EU (which are now countered by the EU with tariffs on american exports) to limit their exports to the US, all the while complaining about Canada doing the same for agricultural products.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI suspect it is about pandering to his base as opposed to health of the nation - assuming it isn't just mindboggling economic illiteracy. He is noticeably promoting trade completely backwards. Normally advanced nations push for more complex, higher capital and infrastructure requirements, or later in the supply chain goods both because of externalities and comparative advantage - any third world nation can cut down trees and allow pollution in - meaning less profit. Instead he has been pushing steel and coal at the expense of finished goods like even kegs. Economically it is like trying to get rich by being a mercantalist colony - the ones that wound up usually lost over mistreatment and doing better after independence. The US makes most profit via services but is still #2 in manufacturing via the advanced end and remained #1 for a while even during their rise. Given the sheer effort and scale involved by China and it cannibalizing world markets to so that is still very impressive. It brings to mind the US agricultural sector - it is at the top and it is still a tiny portion of the GDP. The top end strategy pays economically.