4 ms·
> In the H-Bomb example, what would happen if Oppenheimer didn’t help develop the bomb? Russia most certainly still would have. And the world would be a differe
by Fnoord 8y ago
> In the H-Bomb example, what would happen if Oppenheimer didn’t help develop the bomb? Russia most certainly still would have. And the world would be a different place today.
Russia (or well, actually the Soviet Union) stole the atomic bomb plans via its spy network:
"Although the Soviet scientific community discussed the possibility of an atomic bomb throughout the 1930s,[4][5] going as far as making a concrete proposal to develop such a weapon in 1940,[6][7][8] the full-scale program was initiated only in response to the intelligence reports collected by Soviet intelligence through their spy ring in the United States on the secretive Manhattan Project." [1]
That's the problem with your reasoning ("but they are doing it as well" or "they will do it as well"). Your reasoning is what escalated the Cold War and almost brought us WWIII.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_atomic_bomb_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_atomic_bomb_project
- tashoecraft 8y agoIt's a stretch to say the Soviets stole the atomic bomb plans, if what they got was a rough blueprint of one of the original designs which was not used to produce the size of bomb needed to be useful. The spys may have accelerated the development by a few years at most. Also I believe a lot of the intelligence came a lot from Russia's spy network in the UK, but semantics. It's generally assumed, by Oppenheimer very vocally, that once an atomic bomb would eventually be produced, the physics weren't that complicated, this is coming from him, not me. This was accelerated by the U.S. showing that it could be done, but would not have prevented the development of a bomb. The U.S. couldn't keep researches from publishing fully, eventually the dots would be connected. You state that this is what escalated the Cold war and almost brought us WWIII, well, the cold war was scary and developed lots of proxy wars, but it led to a 60 year time period where two of the largest powers never engaged in direct conflict. It's argued routinely that the only reason for this is both sides have nuclear weapons and the mutual assured destruction idea. If neither side had developed nuclear weapons then there would have certainly been another war between U.S. and Russia.
- Fnoord 8y agoIt almost escalated, multiple times, where it boiled down to someone in lower chain of command refusing to take the destructive action. The book and series The Man In The High Castle (SPOILER) is essentially about the disturbed equilibrium between a nuclear and non nuclear power.
- conjectures 8y agoThis misses the point. Which is that, 'everyone agrees not to do risky things' is not a stable equilibrium. Russia couldn't trust the US not to do it and vice versa.
- Fnoord 8y agoThat lack of risky things is a Fata Morgana. Risky things were done. The world was almost destroyed, multiple times.