4 ms·
>> That looks like astroturfing to you? No, it looks like people exaggerating to me. I don't doubt there is some merit to the safety claims made about Rust, bu
by phkahler 8y ago
>> That looks like astroturfing to you?
No, it looks like people exaggerating to me. I don't doubt there is some merit to the safety claims made about Rust, but many people have a tendency toward unwarranted idealization. I admitted that I have not learned Rust yet which should add doubt to my own skepticism.
The project I'm thinking of trying with Rust looks like it will be predominantly Unsafe Rust - using a lot of structures that are multiply referenced by necessity (or not?). I'm doing a lot of reading and thinking prior to starting because I really want the benefit from Rust as well as changing my thinking if there are good changes to be made there. Using an array of items and having them reference each other by index should satisfy the Rust compiler, but that doesn't actually solve the potential problems of trying to traverse (update) a complex data structure with parallel threads. The challenge of doing this suggests to me that the claims are overblown. A modestly complex data structure seems to require disabling all that safety but I am still learning and contemplating different approaches. Questioning basic assumptions seems prudent. I want to believe, but at this point I'm not convinced.