4 ms·
Is your plan to forbid people from moving to New York so you can freeze time in the 70's? I don't see why people outside NYC wanting to move in means people al
by sp332 8y ago
Is your plan to forbid people from moving to New York so you can freeze time in the 70's?
I don't see why people outside NYC wanting to move in means people already in NYC must accommodate them. SF for example prevents buildings over 4 stories in the downtown area. I live in a much smaller city that mandated brick fronts on all buildings on the main street. And from one perspective it's petty and limiting but my point is, yes NYC residents get to choose what about their city is important to them and protect it. That includes preventing people from moving in if it comes to that.
- dbmikus 8y agoI'm pretty sure that SF restricting building height is a major reason for high real-estate prices that people complain about pricing them out of their homes.
- sp332 8y agoYeah, never quite figured that one out myself.
- kentosi 8y agoSame. When I visited SF I was told that the restriction was due to earthquakes. When I then pointed out the skyscrapers in the city center I was met with shrugs...
- naravara 8y agoI don't really understand this blind-spot people have when it comes to density. There is a vast, vast gulf of building scale in between sprawling suburbs and mid-town Manhattan. Yet any time people want to advocate for densification it's so often insistence that we bulldoze all the townhomes and build up a bunch of towering skyscrapers overnight. You can get really damn dense while still maintaining a human scale. In fact, your city will evolve in a way that makes it more livable and gives it more charming character if you let it go that way. Trying to flip from one layout to another instantly is just going to get you something like Dubai.
- jcadam 8y ago> I don't see why people outside NYC wanting to move in means people already in NYC must accommodate them. I'm rather tired of accommodating snowbirds from NYC down here in Florida during the winter months. But citizens tend to demand freedom of movement within their own country, so...
- sp332 8y agoYeah visiting is a lot different from moving. But you're right that there are some strict regulations on equal access to housing. I think it's going to have to be more specific than just banning people based on geography.
- Analemma_ 8y ago> SF for example prevents buildings over 4 stories in the downtown area. The thing to understand in my comment is that I meant it very literally: the only way to halt these trends if you won't build tons of new housing is to literally forbid people from moving in; i.e. passing a law that blocks outsiders from becoming residents. What San Francisco is doing by preventing high-rise apartments is a lousy proxy for that which is making the situation worse: they think they're keeping people from moving to SF, but the people just move in anyway and price out the existing residents. Anyway, my question was mostly rhetorical. Even the most strident anti-gentrification advocates usually stop short of claiming that people shouldn't be allowed to move in - hence why I asked it, to try and force people to confront the real issue. And if you did pass such a law, I'm almost positive it would be thrown out in court. This is not China; you shouldn't need the government's permission to move to a new house.
- sp332 8y agoWell not in so many words. But since prices are going up, you could provide some kind of subsidy for people who are contributing to the kind of city you want. It could even be as crude as a seniority system. It's not that different from an income-based housing benefit system.
- lovich 8y agoIf you don't constrain the prices or increase as well then the prices will go up forever and your subsidies will get higher and higher. Student loans work like this currently. There is not enough housing for everyone who wants to live in SF to live in SF. Some people are going to lose. If it's left to market forces then the losers are going to be the people with the least money. If you do it randomly it's going to be arbitrary. If you let the government pick and choose who gets in your going to get discrimination as people's biases sneak in. Every approach has advantages and disadvantages so SF is going to have to pick which trade-off it wants unless it builds more housing
- sp332 8y agoWell, instead of companies paying employees money which goes to rent, the city could tax those companies to subsidize the housing instead. That would make similar amounts of money available but the city would have more control over who gets the rent money. Unforeseen consequences abound, I'm just pointing out that rent doesn't have to go up forever.
- mikestew 8y agoI don't see why people outside NYC wanting to move in means people already in NYC must accommodate them. They'll accommodate them one way or the other; the current residents might as well decide how that accommodation takes place. The alternative is: "hi, just moved here with my graduate degree and a job offer to do programming for a financial company. I make lots of money, can anyone rent me a place to stay?" "Of course, my good sir/madam, please give me a moment while we kick poor people out of this 'rustic' condo, make a few adjustments to the rent price..." Sure, there's rent control in NYC to avoid some of this. But that's because the residents never had a choice in accommodating/not accommodating in the first place: the developers did.
- dschuler 8y agoSF has a municipal code that forbids buildings over four stories downtown, but I'm sure you've noticed there are many tall buildings there. This is used as a tool by the city to extract concessions from developers, requiring the city to make an "exception" for essentially every new building.
- gascan 8y agoThat includes preventing people from moving in if it comes to that. I'm not sure people contest that NYC can't do that, I think it's just considered a pretty bad idea that also runs against a lot of American ideals. For example, we usually try to avoid the whole birthright thing. And, what a mess we'd have on our hands if (for example) when Detroit's economy tanked, every other city had closed their doors and Detroit residents effectively weren't allowed to go anywhere else.