3 ms·
> Now with the new "deal" they will take the name North Macedonia but they strictly mention that they do not have any relation to the Ancient Makedonas. So at t
by jcranmer 8y ago
> Now with the new "deal" they will take the name North Macedonia but they strictly mention that they do not have any relation to the Ancient Makedonas. So at the end of the day, why didnt the two goverment or EU or UN take 20 historians and ask them, "guys do they bare the right to have that name?" Whatever the historians say should be the verdict.
The name Macedonia expanded to cover the modern country of Macedonia sometime during the Roman Empire. The historians (well, everyone but the Greeks) would all agree that there is absolutely no issue with calling the modern country of Macedonia from a historical naming perspective. Sure, there's confusion between the Slavic-speaking Macedonians and the Hellenic-speaking Ancient Macedonians, but this is far from the only instance of the same name referring to completely different entities.
- Foivos 8y agoAs you said the Macedonia region covers way more territory than the territory of the modern country. Add to this the fact the nationalists want the modern country to eventually gain all these territories. And before you claim, that these people are minority, having been there it seems that a lot of people share these feelings. For example you can see everywhere maps where the borders of the modern country are way more expanded including a huge part of Greece.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Macedonia region covers way more territory than the territory of the modern country Should people in Western Turkey get pissed off about Greece calling itself Greece?
- DmenshunlAnlsis 8y agoAre you aware of Cyprus?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Foivos 8y agoBased on their claims in Thrace and Aegean sea they are. So I guess you agree with me then.
- tbirrell 8y agoI think thats the point, Greece doesn't want Macedonia to be able to claim the territory of Macedonia by virtue of naming.
- eftychis 8y agoThe consensus of historians is clear. They ignore them because they don't like to side with any single country. Think of it more like politicians ignoring consensus about Global Warming (e.g. Trump as an obvious example) or financial issues. Politicians do not care about what is right, or what the scientific community thinks. They want to make things easier for them.