2 ms·
I bring up anti-vaxxers as a clear example. There are any number of other examples I could bring up, including from content area experts. For examples, the curr
by eesmith 8y ago
I bring up anti-vaxxers as a clear example. There are any number of other examples I could bring up, including from content area experts. For examples, the current medical experiment ethics are in place because of a history of experts more interested in the research results than in people. Eugenics, infamously, was part of established science, but more recently we have found many cases where there have been innumerable wrong convictions based the false science of bite marks, flame patterns, etc., all made by content area experts.
There are also innumerable cases where people - domain experts - react to protect their institution over protecting people. Just look at the reaction of the forensics field to those who have identified major structural problems in forensics. Or look at how universities protect researchers over the many students who have filed sexual harassment claims. Or look to how co-workers often shun whistle blowers who highlight real problems.
As an historical example, a century ago more than 30 Brooklyn physicians opposed the Bureau of Child Health because "If we’re going to save the lives of all the women and children at public expense, what incentive will there be for a young man to go into medicine?” - http://www.harvardsquarelibrary.org/biographies/sara-josephine-baker/ http://www.harvardsquarelibrary.org/biographies/sara-josephi... .
So I don't mean specifically that this argument style is only used to discredit established science, but rather to give an example of how downplaying might look.
As for how to discuss this without using abstractions, that isn't quite my point. Abstractions are fine. What I didn't like was how your abstractions moved the topic away from the concrete details of what appears to be horrible treatment, and into a region where there is no real controversy - abstractions which the article itself used as the baseline for judging what might be unacceptable.
Personally speaking, and here I switch to an abstraction, after reading the many articles where police justify a shooting because they were worried about being attacked - at rates far higher than elsewhere in the world, and with department policies which seem to be biased towards an aggressive style - and stories of police using forced medical exams, and the stories of supposed 'content area experts' in forensics using false science for decades to reinforce police power, my presumption has become more that there is a systemic bias towards the use of power to enforce a level of compliance which is inhumane.
For perhaps the starkest contrast in prison treatment, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfEsz812Q1I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HfEsz812Q1I . (Haldane is likely the most extreme example of a humane prison, and not typical of European prisons, so this isn't quite fair.)
Do you have an idea of what people in your position do in other countries, like those in Western Europe? We rarely hear about British police throwing flash grenades by accident into a baby's occupied crib. On the same lines, do you think your European counterparts would be doing the same things you do?
- JshWright 8y ago> On the same lines, do you think your European counterparts would be doing the same things you do? Chemical sedation of agitated patients is used in the prehospital setting in Europe, yes.
- eesmith 8y agoYes, I have no doubt of that. My question wasn't of a general nature - of which there is little disagreement - but of all of the situations which you described where you think it would sound awful to someone who doesn't have the same context as you have. Would others in Europe, who deal with agitated patients in a prehospital setting, have a roughly comparable response in how to balance between the best interest of the patient's safety and that of the staff's? I think we can agree that in the police context, that balance is quite different between the US and much of Western Europe. I think the perceived risk is lower in Europe, which affects that balance.